THE GATEPOST
Framingham State's award-winning independent student newspaper since 1932
Search Results
Search this site
4270 results found with an empty search
- GOP Republican hopefuls debate at FSU
By Kerrin Murray Editor-in-Chief The three Republican candidates in the special election for the 5th Congressional District seat debated Sunday evening in front of about 45 FSU students, staff and MetroWest community members in the Forum. Each of the candidates took a few moments out of his two-minute introduction to point out flaws in their opponents’ platforms and strategies for winning against the Democratic nominee. Tom Tierney, a Marine Corps veteran, said, “Massachusetts needs a Republican – they need one bad. … I think I am that Republican.” He said once he is elected, he will focus on saving Social Security, fixing medical care and preventing tax increases. Tierney won the GOP primary for the seat last September and was defeated by then-incumbent U.S. Rep. Edward Markey for the 5th Congressional District seat. Frank Addivinola, an attorney who teaches introduction to law and biological sciences at local colleges, said, “He [referring to Tierney] believes in a platform of higher taxes, single-payer healthcare and greater government regulations.” He emphasized the issues of unemployment and and current immigration reform efforts. He said creating jobs is his top priority and that officials need to enforce the current immigration policies to prevent illegal immigration. “There are many tough issues facing the country right now. We need to make decisions – decisions that will affect all of us and our future,” said Addivinola. Michael Stopa, a nanophysicist at Harvard University, said, “With all due respect to Tom and Frank up here, I am the only candidate sitting up here who has a prayer or a plan of winning in December [the general election is on December 10]. “I think there is nothing wrong with running a race because it’s a yearly hobby [referring to Tierney]. I think there is nothing wrong with running a race because it will embellish the masthead in your law practice [referring to Addivinola],” said Stopa. Stopa said he will fight for “free market principles” once he is elected, and push for more science education. Former Massachusetts Republican Congressman Peter Blute moderated the discussion. The three panelists leading the debate were Ted Dooley, Massachusetts Alliance of College Republicans chairman, Chris Latimer, FSU political science department chair, and Phil Maddocks, editor of the Framingham Tab and Natick Bulletin. Panelist Dooley asked the three candidates how they planned to win over voters who, just months ago, “overwhelmingly voted for President Obama and Senator Warren.” Tierney said he doesn’t consider himself a “liberal. “I tend to be conservative in terms of the state issues and more liberal in terms of national issues,” said Tierney. He said he would like to work with Obama on Social Security, keeping the retirement age down. Additionally, Tierney said he would not get rid of Obamacare but make Medicare optional to citizens 65 years or younger. Stopa said Republicans do well in special elections even though “we have been mowed over recently. “We have seven other Democratic candidates who are complicit with everything going on in Massachusetts that’s bad in the past few years, and are all in lockstep with each other,” said Stopa. He said “Obama fatigue” has set in, especially given recent “scandals” this summer with the IRS and NSA. Stopa added that he has had two-time Obama voters sign his papers in support. “I think it [winning the election] is going to be easier than we think,” said Stopa. Addivinola said he is confident that the country’s current “failed economic policies” will ensure a Republican victory come Election Day. He said he would focus on creating more jobs and “go back to our roots” by supporting smaller government. Stopa said after sending his first daughter off to college this September, he observed, “Universities have a self-imposed socialistic policy. … The universities themselves impose a sliding scale and base it [cost of student tuition] on need.” Addivinola said his experience teaching at many local colleges has allowed him to witness first-hand the struggles students face paying for school and avoiding debt. “Many institutions have accelerated the cost of education and it is now very expensive to be a student at school. … Too much administration and special interests within the school itself are factors of the skyrocketing price of education,” said Addivinola. Tierney said the total cost of his full-year tuition at Boston College in 1964 was $11,050. “The cost of education is out of control,” said Tierney. He said he believes in a student loan program that allows students to pay back their loans by taking a percentage of their income. “It lets the student who has the loan repay it in a way that is affordable to him or her,” said Tierney. Stopa said the most important issue America faces right now is the need for Congress to focus on economic growth. “We’ve had anemic growth for the five years of the Obama administration. … If we don’t have that kind of [economic] growth, we are not going to have the kind of revenue that we need to retire the debt,” said Stopa. He said jobs are directly tied to this because “we have so many people out of work, and they’re not paying taxes.” Tierney said Congress must focus on taxes because it is one of the key factors to solving the growing national debt. “The Bush-Cheney tax program must be repealed. … The government has to be proactive,” said Tierney. Addivinola disagreed with Tierney and said Congress will not solve the national debt by “focusing on taxes. “The budget cannot grow. … We need to have prosperity in the United States. In order to do that, we need a smaller government,” said Addivinola. When it comes to national security, Tierney “reluctantly” would give the NSA broad surveillance power. “We do lose a little of our freedoms, but in turn, we save six million lives.” Stopa immediately disagreed with Tierney, adding that the NSA is “too powerful. “National security – what is outlined now – isn’t a perfect piece of legislation,” said Stopa. He added that the real focus should be on human intelligence and recognize the “underlying problem” is terrorism. Chip Jones, of Worcester, said, “I’ve been in Massachusetts politics since [former Massachusetts Gov. Paul Cellucci.] The most improved candidate in only a year-and-a-half is Frank Addivinola. It is frightening that the leader in the polls is a liberal Democrat [referring to Tierney].” Melissa Numan, of Framingham, said, “Massachusetts really needs a Republican. I would like to see some change and Addivinola is that change.” Frank Gerety, of Ashland, said, “I was able to attend both the Democratic and Republican debates, so I got a sense of every candidate. I think it is important to be aware of every option you have, and not just listen to one side.” Joan Murphy, of Medway, said, “Each of the candidates tonight relayed a promising platform. I admired their collective push for change – that is what this district needs.”
- Music Review: Matthew Good’s ‘Arrows of Desire’
By Michael B. Murphy Editorial Staff After the release of Matthew Good’s “Lights of Endangered Species” album in 2011, many fans of the Canadian musician wondered if Good had fallen too far down the rabbit hole of complex and intricately arranged alternative rock music. Would he ever release a more easily accessible album that harkened back to his earlier work? On Sept. 24, Good answered that question affirmatively when he released “Arrows of Desire,” a stripped-down rock record that, sonically and lyrically, more closely resembles the work of his former group The Matthew Good Band than his later and more experimental solo releases. When Good announced earlier this year that he would be making a return to an earlier and more commercially viable sound on “Arrows of Desire” – the title of which was taken from a line found in the William Blake poem “And Did Those Feet in Ancient Time” – many fans wondered if this was a commercial rather than a creative decision. Though the songs found on “Arrows of Desire” are rather straightforward, to say Good sacrificed his creativity in making this record would be way off the mark. Unlike “Lights of Endangered Species” – which was heavily influenced by modern and big band jazz as well as the post rock sounds of Explosions in the Sky – “Arrows of Desire” was birthed out of Good’s love for the alternative rock music of the late ‘80s and the early ‘90s. Good has stated in several interviews that his rediscovery of such bands as The Afghan Whigs and The Pixies was what inspired him to make his latest record. As always the case with Matthew Good songs, the lyrics on “Arrows of Desire” are unapologetically politically charged. The title track, inspired by the US military’s continued use of drones in the Middle East, tells the story of an arrow hurtling through the air, sailing above a battle as it flies in closer to its target. The song almost seems upbeat as one listens to Good sing the chorus – “Up in thin air, we lie in wait.” The mood of the song suggests that what waits up high could be angelic, but it is when he sings “Over the fire / a time to bear / what those below wait / here’s my golden spear / here’s my cold despair,” the sinister intentions of what soars through the sky become clear. The second track, “Via Dolorosa” – Latin for “Way of Grief,” and the name of the street Jesus walked while carrying his cross in Jerusalem – is, lyrically, an unsettling song. In “Via Dolorosa,” Good sings before maniacally repeating the mantra of “Wait till I get my head on straight / Wait till I get my crown on straight / Wait till I get my cross on straight.” Despite the dark lyrics, the track is an easy contender for the album’s best song due to its crunching guitar riffs, intense pre-chorus buildup and that dynamite chorus. It is perhaps Good’s most infectiously catchy rock song in almost a decade. Good’s fondness for early ‘90s rock is most notable on the album’s first single, “Had it Coming.” The spoken word vocals in the verses, the bouncing drumbeat and sing-along chorus are reminiscent of Frank Black and Kim Deal’s work in The Pixies. The rock ‘n’ roll fury reaches its apex on “We’re Long Gone,” which sounds like a mash-up of The Who, ‘90s pop-rocker Matthew Sweet and indie darlings The Hold Steady, after which the album’s tempo drops and its tone becomes more ominous. The excellent “Garden of Knives” has a chugging bass line that dominates the song. Good’s lyrics are perhaps at their most impenetrable as he snarls, “My love screams / Yeah, I like the second half / All in between honeycomb legs / I’ll break your back.” Swirling guitars begin to squeal like buzz saws, pounded piano keys tick along like a metronome as Good warns us, “No matter where the sun strikes us / Knives will grow.” The following track, “Mutineering,” sounds similarly foreboding, but hopefulness bleeds through when the chorus reminds those listening that the evils of the world, “No, they don’t got you yet.” No song on the album best captures Matthew Good’s old style more so than “Hey Hell Heaven.” Fans familiar with his early albums such as “Underdogs” and “Beautiful Midnight” could easily mistake “Hey Hell Heaven” as a lost b-side to those two albums. It’s with this song that one wonders if Good was not only nostalgic with the early sounds of alternative ‘90s rock, but also nostalgic of a time when he was able to just pick up a guitar and write meaningful rock songs. Are the densely layered instrumentations that have largely defined his solo work sorely missed while listening to “Arrows of Desire?” Maybe. That’ll depend on the listener. But one cannot deny the fact that by revisiting the sounds of early ‘90s alternative rock, as well as his earlier sound, Good has created a wonderful addition to his expanding body of work.
- Michael Mack recounts his life-changing experience to FSU community image
By Scott Calzolaio Staff Writer The melody of a church hymn filled DPAC as Michael Mack walked center stage. His only props: a desk with a phone and a laptop, a chair, a piano and a blackboard containing three words – “Heart and Soul.” Mack, a playwright, poet and performer, brought his striking one-man show, “Conversations with My Molester: A Journey of Faith” to FSU last Wednesday, Sept. 18, as part of the President’s Distinguished Lecture series. The series, now running for its third year, was created in 2011. According to Interim President Robert Martin, it was created “to bring to campus presentations on thought-provoking issues, ideas and thoughts.” The theme of this year’s series is “Live to the Truth.” Through a series of descriptive monologues, Mack opened up and told his gripping story, beginning at his childhood. “Before I knew the Magna Carta, treble clef, mitosis, meiosis or the German word for Sun, I knew one thing: I wanted to be a priest,” he said. “I knew it like I knew how to ride a bicycle. It was easy.” He established a precise image of his deep religious beliefs, then went on to describe the single event that changed his life and perception forever. He was just 11 years old in Brevard, North Carolina when he snuck into the basement of the church and found a piano. “I’m just playing,” Mack told the priest as he came downstairs. The priest told Mack, “I’m playing too. I’ve got a project upstairs sewing costumes for an Easter play. It’s our Lord’s resurrection on stage! Would you like to help?” Mack soon found himself in the rectory with the door closing behind him, about to endure a life-changing experience. Though leaving out most of the the audience got the picture of what occurred in the rectory that day. “When father opened the door to let me out, he put his finger to his lips and swore me to a secret… I felt like someone else, different, special, cupping a secret.” Four days after the incident, the priest moved out of town without saying a word, and the Mack family left soon after, five hundred miles to Washington. He said that he, “would pray to forget Brevard, but the memory tingled like a phantom limb, sticking out sideways… the phantom limb that itched and crawled and I was the only one who knew, well I and one other.” At age 14, Mack had far from come to terms with this occurrence. “I would return to that memory again and again and again in fantasy, powerfully attracted and powerfully repelled, finding self-loathing its own dismal ecstasy, each turn proving to me that I wanted it to happen, invited it to happen, made it happen, deserved it.” He yearned to have a conversation with the priest, with his molester. He would practice and rehearse what he might say. When Mack became a camp counselor at age 16, the memory still burned. He came close to becoming a predator himself as he helped console a camp goer that wasn’t feeling well. He described himself moving in closer to the boy, smelling the baby shampoo in his hair, apples on his breath, and radiating warmth of his cheeks, as he put his arm around him and asked, “Hey, wanna help with a project?” Mack described the vivid flashback he had at that moment – a flashback of his own molestation. He quickly withdrew his hand from around the boy realizing the atrocity he almost committed and he told the boy he should go, all the while thinking, “forgive yourself for what you never did.” In 2005, nearly 40 years following the incident with the priest, Mack finally decided to search for his molester, Father Gordon Ignatius Anderson. He did his research and found his name linked to multiple charges of molestation in the news. Mack picked up the phone and called, but hung up as soon as he heard a voice. He decided to write him a letter instead. It was not until a full three years after it was written that it was sent out. A few weeks after Mack sent his letter, he conducted another Google search, and what he found was astonishing. “Gordon Ignatius Anderson, age 79, killed at home in a fire,” filled news headlines. He realized the conversation he yearned to have would never happen. Mack traveled back to Worchester and attended the priest’s funeral services, where he met Aiden Kincaid and Father Al, friends of Father Gordon, and Mack admitted what had happened that day in the rectory. “It was a very serious problem, the man needed help,” Father Al admitted about his friend Father Gordon. Father Al was very friendly to Mack, asking to meet up with him again and offering introduce him to the group of clergymen that Father Gordon had been spending his time with. The next week Mack tried to call Al, but the line was dead. He tried calling Aiden, but his line was also dead. He turned to Google again for answers, and was shocked at what he saw. Aiden Kincaid, “Defrocked, stripped of his pension. He faces a lawsuit, multiple complaints. One accuser said he was part of a group of men who met at a house and played ‘pass around the boy.’” The audience let out a small gasp as this was revealed. Mack put more emotion into the following five minutes of his performance than the first two hours combined. “The image had already singed my mind… Shame! This child is not your possession, this is God’s child, this child is me! How many years will this child live in the prison of this memory? All his life! 43 years and still it snakes and squirms through my mind! I kneel to pray and I get aroused! I say the word ‘father’ and I cringe.” These were the only moments in his performance where he revealed the true anger that was within him. He concluded his performance with a return to the church where he had been molested to find out it was converted into a children’s art center. He found the new church in town and went to confession for the first time in over 40 years.
- A life in limbo: How $3,500 and the FSU administration’s policy on work visas ruined Vanessa Desani’
By Spencer Buell Editor-in-Chief Pick a card. You are an immigrant named Manuel, who entered the U.S. illegally to flee gang violence in Honduras. You are a cook from Poland named Jan who came here to work in a kitchen, getting paid in cash, when you couldn’t find a job back home. Or you’re Lupe, a migrant farm laborer from Mexico who came here in search of work after being crushed financially when corn prices plummeted. You are undocumented. Place your playing piece, you are instructed, on the “Undocumented Limbo Loop Start” space. Roll the dice. Or maybe you are a Somali with refugee status named Adama, or a Korean named Sue who married someone from the U.S. Place your playing piece on the “Path to Citizenship.” Roll the dice. This is the Immigration Board Game, the brainchild of the non-profit equal rights advocacy group Alliance for a Just Society. Two paths of Monopoly-esque game spaces are laid out on a multicolored playing board encircled by the flags of three dozen countries. End up on one and you move slowly toward the finish line, where, if you are one of the luckier players, you win citizenship: the right to live and work in the U.S. without fear of deportation. The right to vote. But end up on the other, and you are in limbo. As you roll the dice, your journey takes you through victories and enormous hardships – good jobs, bad ones, illnesses, financial burdens. If you are in limbo, you soon realize there is no finish line. You move your playing piece around the board in an endless loop, trying to earn a living for yourself and pay your bills while carefully avoiding being detained by immigration officials and running the risk of being deported, of having to start the loop all over again. You will never become a citizen, and there is almost nothing you can do to change that. Those are the rules. For you, this is just a game. But for tens of thousands living in Massachusetts, this is life – dreams of becoming legal, honest-to-goodness U.S. citizens, but years spent in a ceaseless, futile journey toward a finish line it is unlikely they will ever reach. That is, unless some kind of miracle, a lucky break or a clever scheme helps them onto the inside track. “Some of my students got frustrated as they started to realize it was really kind of a flip of a coin,” says FSU Sociology Professor Vincent Ferraro, who used the game as a teaching tool in a sociology course on immigration last semester. “And that’s actually more true to life than many of us would like to think. … You can do everything right, you can do everything that’s asked of you, and never quite get there, which is so antithetical to the American idea that working hard will eventually get you there.” For Vanessa Desani, a Brazilian native and a former instructor in Framingham State’s ESL program, the board game is all too real. To be clear, Desani has never been in this country illegally, not even for a day. For the six years she has been in the U.S., she has maintained a chain of legal, government-issued immigration paperwork – the “documents” undocumented immigrants lack. And until last summer, she thought her job at FSU meant she was on the inside track, the path to becoming a citizen and obtaining the right to do the work she loves. She didn’t know it then, but from the moment she arrived in New York State all those years ago, citizenship has been outside her grasp. To her horror, she has realized she has been in limbo from the very beginning. Sitting in a Brazilian bakery called the Magic Oven on Waverly Street in downtown Framingham in mid-January, Vanessa Desani is visibly distraught. Through red wire glasses tucked under bleached blonde hair, her eyes look searchingly over her right shoulder to where, outside, the clouds are heavy with impending rain and the commuter rail rolls east toward Boston. In red and yellow booths behind her, people are squirting ketchup on fried, meat-filled balls and eating with gusto, but she isn’t hungry. Next week, she will start the second semester of a graduate interdisciplinary program at Cambridge College for another master’s degree, one she doesn’t need – her twentieth year of being a student, her sixth in a country not her own. She couldn’t find any online courses this time, so she will have to commute to Boston twice a week. Her courses have been interesting so far, and she hopes some of her work toward an interdisciplinary studies major will be of use to her when she can finally get another shot at being an educator and community advocate, when she is finally legally allowed to have a job again. But this latest stint in college is not about gaining more knowledge or experience – she believes she has plenty of both already. It is about keeping herself from becoming undocumented. As long as she is a student, she can have a student visa. She will not be forced out of the country by immigration officials, or have to live under the radar in fear of being caught without paperwork. She can stay in the country. And at least for now, that is the best she can hope for. Last summer, when Desani’s temporary work authorization was up for renewal, Framingham State administrators decided not to fill out the necessary paperwork and pay the $3,500 in fees for her visa. When she pleaded with administrators to sponsor her, when she explained the disastrous impact she knew this decision would have on her life, she was told that, per school policy, Framingham State does not sponsor work visas for part-time contractors such as ESL instructors. According to Rita Colucci, the school’s chief of staff and general counsel, FSU only provides work visas for high-level administrators and tenure-track professors. “Vanessa requested that we make an exception to our policy and we said ‘no,’” Colucci says. Those are the rules. Although the deadline for Desani’s visa renewal kept getting closer and closer by the day during her stint as a teacher, she said she didn’t worry. After all the years of academic achievements and community outreach she had undertaken to land this job and expand the ELP program, she thought Framingham State couldn’t possibly let her go. Not over a paltry $3,500 – a fee it would be illegal for her to pay herself, and which the school would have to shoulder. Now, she knows how naïve she really was. “I don’t know why, but I was so hopeful. I thought things would work.” When a petition in support of keeping Desani on FSU’s payroll circulated around the downtown Framingham area garnered over 400 signatures from community members, administrators still wouldn’t budge. “Framingham and the surrounding communities are writing you this letter to ask that you do everything in your power to help Vanessa Desani to get her work visa status at Framingham State University,” the petition, originally sent to State Rep. Tom Sannicandro, reads. “We admire her tenacity and work ethic and we truly believe that her presence in the community and at FSU is an asset to all of us, not just to her students.” The way Desani tells it, she met with both Colucci and President Timothy Flanagan and presented them with the signatures, and once even slid a copy under the president’s door. But asked on several occasions, no administrator has said on the record that he or she has seen it. Not one. By the end of the fall 2012 semester, at an administrators’ question-and-answer meeting for students in North Hall, Flanagan claimed he still had not seen the petition, and could not even attest to its existence. “I’m aware that it’s said to exist,” he said that Tuesday in November. “I have not physically seen that petition.” Due to the school’s policy on “personnel matters” such as reasons for employees being laid off, most cannot say much. But here is the school’s version of what happened. “I don’t doubt that she had a petition,” Colucci says. “I don’t think she would have lied about that. … I also have a terrible memory.” At their meeting together, Colucci says, “She certainly had something that, she was saying, ‘I have a petition here.’ Most certainly. … But at the end of the day,” Colucci says, “petitions are great, but just because you have a petition doesn’t mean that what you’re asking for is going to be granted.” “We didn’t get the response that we thought we would get,” says Fernanda Alves, who coordinated the effort to collect the signatures, leading a team of 10 who canvassed downtown community centers, churches and hangouts for supporters. Alves works as a mental health counselor at the South Middlesex Opportunity Council, and she and Desani are close. The way Alves tells it, administrators know about the petition, and have all along. “I myself sent it,” she says. “I know they got it. I don’t know why they don’t acknowledge it. … It feels like we’re being ignored.” When Desani realized there was nothing she or anyone else could do to keep her on the FSU staff, she says her journey, which began in São Paulo, Brazil and brought her to FSU, felt as if it had come to an abrupt halt. Desani says she pleaded with Flanagan and Colucci. “How am I going to be away from my students?” she asked them. “I can’t. I just can’t. I love them so much.” When the reality of her predicament finally set in, she says, “For the first time in five years, I felt like an immigrant.” Desani first arrived in the U.S in March of 2007 through an au pair exchange program out of her native Brazil. She had just graduated from São Paulo University, one of the most prestigious schools in South America, and took the opportunity to travel to New York to work and study with a government-issued J-1 visa. She worked there as a nanny before deciding to transfer to Greater Boston to become an au pair in Needham. At the time, she thought coming to Massachusetts would give her the opportunity to practice her English without being around other Brazilians. Boston was too cold for Brazilians, she thought. “And then I started driving the 135 to Framingham, and I couldn’t believe my eyes,” she says. Ethnic restaurants. The Magic Oven. Greens and yellows. Portuguese. She had found an unexpected second home in central Massachusetts, and, although she had been thinking of heading back home, decided then that she would stay, that she would explore the possibilities the downtown would hold for her. “That was the happiest day of my life.” She soon noticed, after making regular trips to the downtown and befriending many of its residents, that Framingham was in desperate need of more English language educators. Many spoke little English, if any at all, and had gotten used to communicating with other Lusophones, or Portuguese-speakers, living in their immediate vicinity. If she worked hard enough, she could change that, she thought. She could help people learn the language so they would be able to further their educations at local universities and community colleges, or communicate with their children’s public school teachers. When her term of service as an au pair was up, she decided to stay, and to pursue a master’s degree in English as a Second Language at Cambridge College. For her thesis, she spent dozens of hours in Framingham, as well as Marlborough and Somerville, chronicling the language deficiency issues in those communities. Her thesis, it bears repeating, was a study of Framingham State’s backyard and the residents and their children who live here. In other words, Desani is an expert on the lives, struggles and ambitions of the men and women who could very well make up the student body of FSU in the decades to come. After she graduated, and her 12-month period of legal work authorization, called Optional Practical Training, began in August of 2011, she got a job teaching ESL courses at Framingham State – a job she thought would be hers for as long as she wanted it. “In my head, I’m like, ‘I have an education. I have my master’s,” Desani says, a fat binder filled with her thesis research on the table in front of her. “I kept thinking, ‘I’m here. I’m fine.’” But after hearing “no” so many times – “‘No, we can’t do it, no, no, no,’” she says, “I just feel like I have to start over my life.” It’s a snowy Tuesday night in March, and the streets of downtown are coated with a thin, slick layer of slush. One by one, eight students, ages 25 to 54, are making their way to the third floor of a building (area undisclosed, by request), purple English textbooks and today’s homework in tow. “Foundations,” it is called – the study materials for an introductory-level ESL course. A woman going by the name Lucay, 54, cleaned five houses today, as she does every day. A man named Margins, also 54, logged a full workday on a construction site. Some are a little late – the weather made walking or driving here more difficult – but they’re here. They are learning nationalities today. “You are from Brazil, so you are?” their teacher asks. A pause. They squint their eyes, thinking. “Brazilian,” she tells them. “Brazilian,” they repeat. In a close-knit community where almost everyone with whom they interact speaks Portuguese, they haven’t had to know the word. In Framingham, just like back home, they are Brasileiro, Brasileira. Every member of the class is undocumented. For many, it’s relatively easy to get by in Framingham without learning to speak English. If new arrivals to the town speak Portuguese, they can go about their day buying groceries, ordering coffee and working jobs that don’t necessarily require communication skills – cleaning or building houses, cooking, mowing lawns. Tony, 37, a used tire salesman, picked up a few English words over the years downtown, but the language barrier has started getting in the way of his business, and he decided he finally needed to learn to speak English. “It’s not easy for me because I don’t speak it well,” he says. “I need to learn.” Saaron, a 45-year-old housecleaner, says she wants to build a better relationship with her employers. A few weeks ago, while cleaning a shelf, an ornament fell and smashed into pieces. She left her employer money to replace it, but had to use web service Google Translate to explain what happened in a handwritten note. In the future, she wants to be able to apologize in person. Nixon and Silana, who, at ages 25 and 30 are the youngest in the group, said they wanted to be able to meet English-speaking people in their new home in Framingham. Both arrived within the last year. Recently, Silana says, an English-speaking man approached her at the gym, trying to flirt with her. She misunderstood, thinking he wanted to use the machine she’d been using. Embarrassed, she ended the conversation, and the encounter felt like a missed opportunity. “I want to live here,” Silana says, through an interpreter. “How can I not learn to speak English? I love to talk!” Nixon and Silana are both hopeful they will be able to stay in Massachusetts, assimilate, make friends, and possibly go to college. Nixon is considering studying physical education, but if things don’t work out for him here, if he can’t continue to support himself in a new country, he says, learning English can help him get a job back home. Silana says being able to speak English would give her a huge competitive edge in Brazil, a country where more and more job applicants have college degrees. Margins, 54, says learning the language means protecting himself in dire situations, such as talking to the police or with angry English-speaking neighbors. “If you don’t speak English, there are a lot of problems,” he says. His classmates nod in agreement. Darilson has gotten by for the last 10 years knowing basically no English, but when his son started first grade this year, the 32-year-old decided to finally put in the effort and start taking ESL classes. “I want to learn for my son,” he says. As one of the two or three most proficient speakers in the class, he’s speaking for himself, slowly and calculatingly. “He says, ‘Dad, read my book,’ but I can’t.” At his house, his son speaks Portuguese. Darilson does not want him to forget the language of his heritage, but also, until now, Portuguese has been the only means of communication between them, and Darilson didn’t want to lose that. He will raise his son to be bilingual, and now he wants to be bilingual, too. If he wants to talk to his son’s friends and teachers, help him with his homework, read his books, he will have to. For those in Framingham who want to learn English, there are a few options. There is the Framingham Adult ESL Plus program, which runs on a lottery system. Hundreds line up for the free classes, funded through a grant from the Mass. Dept. of Education, but slots are limited. When people don’t get into those classes, they look elsewhere. Some look to other free, or cheap classes through local non-profits, some of which charge as little as $50. Some seek out private tutors, and others come to Framingham State. It was at this point in people’s lives that Desani used to intervene. As a Plus volunteer, and a well-known face downtown, she used to steer students to FSU, promising a top-notch education, even if it did cost some money – $370 per semester, for many, is a sizable financial commitment to make. But Desani used to sell the FSU program based on its merit, and on the benefits of getting a certificate of completion from an accredited state university. She would hand out informational pamphlets she translated herself from English to Portuguese – before Desani, those pamphlets were written exclusively in English. And Framingham’s residents listened. “She recruited many students,” says Rebecca Hawk, director of FSU’s ELP and community education programs. “Scores of students.” In a picture from a Boston Globe article about the ELP program, Desani is smiling, helping one of her students work through an assignment. This was the old Vanessa, the one who played music for her students, the one who snapped her fingers and danced around the classroom. The one her students called chuchu, pronounced like “shoo-shoo” – my dear. She called them chuchu, as well. The picture was taken in August, on her very last day as an instructor, before a replacement was brought in to finish teaching the remaining weeks of the class. That, Desani says, hurt more than anything – that she was not allowed to finish teaching the students she had been with since the beginning of the semester. The wounds, she says, may never heal. But in the picture, she is smiling. “The community wanted me to be there. They wanted me there to help with translations, with offices, with classes, because they felt like they belonged there. They could say, ‘This is somebody who came from the same place and is at the university. If she can be there, I can be there.’” Twelve months before administrators ran out the clock on Desani, making it illegal for her to hold her job, she was doing what she loved, with students who loved her back. After having spent so much time in their midst conducting her thesis research, Desani understood that many of her night students worked long, long hours, sometimes performing strenuous manual labor, and she needed to do something special to grab their attention, to make them want to learn. “My students work 10 hours a day, cleaning four or five houses, going to class at 7 o’clock. If I don’t do a very funny class, play music, make them jump, they will fall asleep on their desks. They are painters, they are landscapers, they are house cleaners, so I try to encourage my students. I like to make them rise and make them laugh.” Although DGCE doesn’t encourage instructors to do so, Desani also gave her students her cell phone number, and told them to call her at any time. Difficulties with their English homework, immigration issues, whatever, they could call. From her time spent as a translator at the Framingham District Court, helping to keep immigrants from signing deportation documents they couldn’t read, she understood the perils of not knowing English, or of having a limited knowledge of it in emergencies. In particular, Desani remembers the widespread panic among her students after a car accident in Milford in the summer of 2011 that, for many, changed everything. Recent FSU graduate Matt Denice was hit and killed while riding his motorcycle in August of that year, and the driver was an undocumented Ecuadorian immigrant who was heavily intoxicated and driving without a driver’s license. The horrific accident sparked local outcry against illegal immigrants in the town, and Desani’s students, many of whom also did not have driver’s licenses, saw traffic stops skyrocket. Shortly after the accident, half of her students, all of them from Milford, dropped her class, scared to brave the streets to drive to Framingham. “My students said, ‘Vanessa … a guy in a raincoat is stopping cars and asking for documents.’ They were afraid,” Desani says. “And I was the first one to say, ‘OK, don’t come to my class. I don’t want to be responsible for any deportations. I understand.’ “If they lived closer,” she adds, “I would have offered them rides.” One student, Desani says, after being arrested twice for driving without a license, just left for home, ashamed and embarrassed after being labeled a criminal. “It was terrible,” she says. These are Desani’s people, “illegal” or not. And she was determined to help them as much as she could – that is, before the rules, the laws and policies, drove her and her students apart. Desani came to FSU during a period of transition and renewal for the English language and community education programs. When former ESL Coordinator Lavonne Krishnan retired in 2008 after eight years at that post, the school spent four years hiring several other candidates to take her place, but, for one reason or another, each didn’t fit. Eventually, the school brought on Rebecca Hawk, giving her the new title of “director” of the newly merged community ed and ELP programs. Hawk says she was astonished by the predominance of the Lusophone population in Framingham and surrounding communities when she arrived here, and began overseeing attempts to reinvigorate DGCE’s efforts to recruit non-native English speakers. “‘Community education’ could mean many things,” Hawk says, and for Framingham, that meant teaching the town’s many new immigrants how to speak English, thereby preparing them for further studies – “funneling” students into night courses in business or other disciplines. In addition, renovations to the Maynard Building in Framingham Centre were well underway and the school had begun relocating classrooms and administrative offices to the new location across Route 9. DGCE was, and still is, ramping up spending on outreach – Greenberg says last year alone, FSU spent nearly $10,000 on print and radio ads, postcards and handouts. For three days a week, Desani taught morning and evening classes in the McCarthy Center, putting in extra, unpaid hours working late in her office to put together outreach materials. As a guest on AM 650, a locally operated Portuguese-language radio station, she would field questions from residents. “You have to stop watching soap operas and come to school!” she would say, playfully attempting to tease listeners out of their comfort zones. “When I met Vanessa,” Hawk says, “I saw that she had this passion to connect with the community.” Desani had been with the program for just a month, but had big ideas, passion and a strong work ethic. The timing, back then, seemed perfect. “The first task at hand was to make our ELP program more accessible to the community,” Hawk says. The word “accessible” is an important one, she says, because crafting programs and making courses “available” to students is not enough – not for those who speak no English at all, or who simply have not considered studying the language at FSU because no one has made the effort to recruit them. Before Desani and Hawk arrived at Framingham State, Portuguese-speaking residents would call, curious about the program, but no one was on staff who could speak with them in their own language. “Sorry,” ELP personnel would say. “No Portuguese.” Today, no one on the DGCE staff is fluent in Spanish or Portuguese, and no one is making claims of being “bilingual.” Hawk herself can speak some Portuguese, but not enough that she could conduct phone conversations confidently. Desani could communicate freely and easily with community members, building a relationship it would be nearly impossible for other ELP staff to replicate. Having Desani on staff meant having an employee who was the triple threat Hawk needed: she was bilingual, she was trained as an educator and she undertook a proactive, community advocacy-oriented approach to her job. In Framingham, Desani says, “I thought, ‘I need to reach my community. How am I going to do this? I have to communicate in Portuguese so people can know more about the university.’ So that’s what I did.” To Hawk and Desani, being an ESL teacher is about more than offering instruction on how to speak English. Much more. Desani first learned to speak the language while studying at São Paulo, but instead of actually learning English, she says, she learned something else entirely – how not to teach a language. Her professor refused to speak Portuguese in the classroom, insisting that she and her classmates learn in total immersion. “I couldn’t help but cry,” she says. “I said to my mom, ‘I’m not coming back. I couldn’t understand a word he said.’” She likens that classroom in southern Brazil to the ones at Framingham State. Here, though, it isn’t that the professors won’t speak their students’ language, be it Portuguese or Spanish, Chinese or German. They just can’t. “That’s a big problem,” Desani says. “Especially if you think about community education.” After Desani’s termination, Hawk says, many of her students left as well, some of them vowing to follow their teacher to her next job. “It was a severe drop-off when she left. … I’d say we’re in a period of recovery from that.” “She was dynamic,” she says, “and she filled a niche that is very difficult to fill. … Not having her here is a tremendous loss. It’s a loss for the community and for us, actually.” To this day, Hawk still hears complaints from the community about the ELP losing Desani – “that still comes out in the dialogues,” she says. “I tell them, ‘It’s a very difficult decision, and I’m sorry it didn’t happen as well as it could have, but we still have a good program, and we can still teach you English, so please come here.” She has been trying to maintain Desani’s connections to the community in her absence. A Portuguese-speaking FSU underclassman from Brazil started working in the office on a volunteer basis this semester – explaining the ELP program to locals in their own language, just as Desani did. Greenberg says DGCE is in the process of hiring a long-term bilingual employee, and will begin interviewing applicants next week. In the meantime, Hawk has even been making guest appearances on AM 650 and making the case for FSU over the airwaves, just as Desani did. But it isn’t the same, she says. She can only speak with the help of a translator, and can’t connect with listeners based on the shared experience of learning English after arriving here from South America. The distinction is simple: like many downtown residents, Desani came from Brazil to a foreign country, and worked for years to learn the language. Hawk didn’t. Desani can speak from experience about the difference learning English can make as a non-American. Hawk can’t. “The same place you’re sitting now,” Desani used to tell her students, “I was there, learning English here, like you are doing.” Of the 300 ELP students enrolled last semester, 51 percent spoke Portuguese as their primary language. This semester, Hawk expects that figure to swell to 60 percent or more. This is the community with which she is working, and she wishes something could be done to bring Desani back to help meet its needs. “It is complicated and I understand the school’s policy, but sometimes a need arises and a policy needs to be assessed. The world that we live in is becoming more and more global,” she says, adding, “sometimes exceptions need to be made in anticipation of what the need could be.” Less than a mile away from FSU, thousands of Portuguese-speaking residents are listening to their radios, hanging out in bakeries, working long hours babysitting or doing manual labor around town, and Hawk wants to help them learn to speak English, to become part- or even full-time students at Framingham State. But now, she has to do it without Desani. “From the university’s standpoint,” Hawk says, “I think it’s a missed opportunity.” FSU is not the only employer which has rejected Desani due to her immigration status over the last few months. She says she has probably been to interviews at a dozen colleges and universities – Tufts, Bentley, Northeastern among them – and each has progressed in what is now a predictable pattern: the conversation will go well, the interviewer will seem impressed and will sometimes even ask for her availability, will ask how soon she can start teaching. Then, she breaks it to them. “Well, here it comes,” she has started saying out loud. “Immigrant.” “Visa.” “Thirty-five hundred dollars.” Then, the interview ends, the interviewer apologizes, says there is nothing he or she can do, and Desani goes home. Often, she prays. “God helps me, but I have to move, too. Its hard for me because I have been waiting for something, and I don’t know what to do.” She stubbornly refuses to let her spirit be broken, although she isn’t sure how much longer she can do this – how much longer she can live in limbo. “I feel that something is going to work out, but right now I have no idea,” she says, seemingly a bit surprised by how pessimism has started creeping up on her. “You know when you’re completely lost? I don’t know what to do. ” She pauses. “Something is going to work. I don’t think things happen just because. Something will work.” She pauses again. “But some days I feel like I should just pack up all my stuff and go back. But that’s not typical of me.” Just after New Year’s Day, Desani felt lumps in her chest, and fearing she might have breast cancer, saw a specialist. Her diagnosis? High levels of stress had caused some severe tightening in her pectoral muscles. “The lady doing the test, she said to me, ‘I know what your problem is. You have immigration pains. You have immigration pains in your chest.’” To this day, Desani still has trouble sleeping. She wakes up with anxiety about what the future will hold, clinging to the hope that God will intervene and make something happen. Her mother lives in Brazil, along with the rest of her family, and they all seem to think she should just admit defeat and return home. Either that or go back to school and get a degree in science or engineering – the kinds of degrees that lead to visas in a country where employers are falling over themselves to attract the world’s top STEM workers. But Desani wants to teach, and she wants to be an advocate for the disadvantaged, and above all, she wants to do it here. “I don’t know why,” she says. “I wish it was different. I wish I could be a doctor. I decided to come here for one year to learn English. It has been six years. Why? Is it because I like the weather? No. Is it because I like to be alone without my family? No.” It is because she is passionate about teaching, about providing Framingham’s Portuguese-speaking residents with hope and opportunity to succeed when their futures, like hers, can be uncertain – at the whim of a system that can feel designed to make them fail. But until she can find some way out of limbo, some lucky break, it seems as if no one on this campus, in this state or in this country will let her do it. They can’t, they say. Those are the rules.
- A life in limbo: How $3,500 and the FSU administration’s policy on work visas ruined Vanessa Desani’
By Spencer Buell Editor-in-Chief Pick a card. You are an immigrant named Manuel, who entered the U.S. illegally to flee gang violence in Honduras. You are a cook from Poland named Jan who came here to work in a kitchen, getting paid in cash, when you couldn’t find a job back home. Or you’re Lupe, a migrant farm laborer from Mexico who came here in search of work after being crushed financially when corn prices plummeted. You are undocumented. Place your playing piece, you are instructed, on the “Undocumented Limbo Loop Start” space. Roll the dice. Or maybe you are a Somali with refugee status named Adama, or a Korean named Sue who married someone from the U.S. Place your playing piece on the “Path to Citizenship.” Roll the dice. This is the Immigration Board Game, the brainchild of the non-profit equal rights advocacy group Alliance for a Just Society. Two paths of Monopoly-esque game spaces are laid out on a multicolored playing board encircled by the flags of three dozen countries. End up on one and you move slowly toward the finish line, where, if you are one of the luckier players, you win citizenship: the right to live and work in the U.S. without fear of deportation. The right to vote. But end up on the other, and you are in limbo. As you roll the dice, your journey takes you through victories and enormous hardships – good jobs, bad ones, illnesses, financial burdens. If you are in limbo, you soon realize there is no finish line. You move your playing piece around the board in an endless loop, trying to earn a living for yourself and pay your bills while carefully avoiding being detained by immigration officials and running the risk of being deported, of having to start the loop all over again. You will never become a citizen, and there is almost nothing you can do to change that. Those are the rules. For you, this is just a game. But for tens of thousands living in Massachusetts, this is life – dreams of becoming legal, honest-to-goodness U.S. citizens, but years spent in a ceaseless, futile journey toward a finish line it is unlikely they will ever reach. That is, unless some kind of miracle, a lucky break or a clever scheme helps them onto the inside track. “Some of my students got frustrated as they started to realize it was really kind of a flip of a coin,” says FSU Sociology Professor Vincent Ferraro, who used the game as a teaching tool in a sociology course on immigration last semester. “And that’s actually more true to life than many of us would like to think. … You can do everything right, you can do everything that’s asked of you, and never quite get there, which is so antithetical to the American idea that working hard will eventually get you there.” For Vanessa Desani, a Brazilian native and a former instructor in Framingham State’s ESL program, the board game is all too real. To be clear, Desani has never been in this country illegally, not even for a day. For the six years she has been in the U.S., she has maintained a chain of legal, government-issued immigration paperwork – the “documents” undocumented immigrants lack. And until last summer, she thought her job at FSU meant she was on the inside track, the path to becoming a citizen and obtaining the right to do the work she loves. She didn’t know it then, but from the moment she arrived in New York State all those years ago, citizenship has been outside her grasp. To her horror, she has realized she has been in limbo from the very beginning. Sitting in a Brazilian bakery called the Magic Oven on Waverly Street in downtown Framingham in mid-January, Vanessa Desani is visibly distraught. Through red wire glasses tucked under bleached blonde hair, her eyes look searchingly over her right shoulder to where, outside, the clouds are heavy with impending rain and the commuter rail rolls east toward Boston. In red and yellow booths behind her, people are squirting ketchup on fried, meat-filled balls and eating with gusto, but she isn’t hungry. Next week, she will start the second semester of a graduate interdisciplinary program at Cambridge College for another master’s degree, one she doesn’t need – her twentieth year of being a student, her sixth in a country not her own. She couldn’t find any online courses this time, so she will have to commute to Boston twice a week. Her courses have been interesting so far, and she hopes some of her work toward an interdisciplinary studies major will be of use to her when she can finally get another shot at being an educator and community advocate, when she is finally legally allowed to have a job again. But this latest stint in college is not about gaining more knowledge or experience – she believes she has plenty of both already. It is about keeping herself from becoming undocumented. As long as she is a student, she can have a student visa. She will not be forced out of the country by immigration officials, or have to live under the radar in fear of being caught without paperwork. She can stay in the country. And at least for now, that is the best she can hope for. Last summer, when Desani’s temporary work authorization was up for renewal, Framingham State administrators decided not to fill out the necessary paperwork and pay the $3,500 in fees for her visa. When she pleaded with administrators to sponsor her, when she explained the disastrous impact she knew this decision would have on her life, she was told that, per school policy, Framingham State does not sponsor work visas for part-time contractors such as ESL instructors. According to Rita Colucci, the school’s chief of staff and general counsel, FSU only provides work visas for high-level administrators and tenure-track professors. “Vanessa requested that we make an exception to our policy and we said ‘no,’” Colucci says. Those are the rules. Although the deadline for Desani’s visa renewal kept getting closer and closer by the day during her stint as a teacher, she said she didn’t worry. After all the years of academic achievements and community outreach she had undertaken to land this job and expand the ELP program, she thought Framingham State couldn’t possibly let her go. Not over a paltry $3,500 – a fee it would be illegal for her to pay herself, and which the school would have to shoulder. Now, she knows how naïve she really was. “I don’t know why, but I was so hopeful. I thought things would work.” When a petition in support of keeping Desani on FSU’s payroll circulated around the downtown Framingham area garnered over 400 signatures from community members, administrators still wouldn’t budge. “Framingham and the surrounding communities are writing you this letter to ask that you do everything in your power to help Vanessa Desani to get her work visa status at Framingham State University,” the petition, originally sent to State Rep. Tom Sannicandro, reads. “We admire her tenacity and work ethic and we truly believe that her presence in the community and at FSU is an asset to all of us, not just to her students.” The way Desani tells it, she met with both Colucci and President Timothy Flanagan and presented them with the signatures, and once even slid a copy under the president’s door. But asked on several occasions, no administrator has said on the record that he or she has seen it. Not one. By the end of the fall 2012 semester, at an administrators’ question-and-answer meeting for students in North Hall, Flanagan claimed he still had not seen the petition, and could not even attest to its existence. “I’m aware that it’s said to exist,” he said that Tuesday in November. “I have not physically seen that petition.” Due to the school’s policy on “personnel matters” such as reasons for employees being laid off, most cannot say much. But here is the school’s version of what happened. “I don’t doubt that she had a petition,” Colucci says. “I don’t think she would have lied about that. … I also have a terrible memory.” At their meeting together, Colucci says, “She certainly had something that, she was saying, ‘I have a petition here.’ Most certainly. … But at the end of the day,” Colucci says, “petitions are great, but just because you have a petition doesn’t mean that what you’re asking for is going to be granted.” “We didn’t get the response that we thought we would get,” says Fernanda Alves, who coordinated the effort to collect the signatures, leading a team of 10 who canvassed downtown community centers, churches and hangouts for supporters. Alves works as a mental health counselor at the South Middlesex Opportunity Council, and she and Desani are close. The way Alves tells it, administrators know about the petition, and have all along. “I myself sent it,” she says. “I know they got it. I don’t know why they don’t acknowledge it. … It feels like we’re being ignored.” When Desani realized there was nothing she or anyone else could do to keep her on the FSU staff, she says her journey, which began in São Paulo, Brazil and brought her to FSU, felt as if it had come to an abrupt halt. Desani says she pleaded with Flanagan and Colucci. “How am I going to be away from my students?” she asked them. “I can’t. I just can’t. I love them so much.” When the reality of her predicament finally set in, she says, “For the first time in five years, I felt like an immigrant.” Desani first arrived in the U.S in March of 2007 through an au pair exchange program out of her native Brazil. She had just graduated from São Paulo University, one of the most prestigious schools in South America, and took the opportunity to travel to New York to work and study with a government-issued J-1 visa. She worked there as a nanny before deciding to transfer to Greater Boston to become an au pair in Needham. At the time, she thought coming to Massachusetts would give her the opportunity to practice her English without being around other Brazilians. Boston was too cold for Brazilians, she thought. “And then I started driving the 135 to Framingham, and I couldn’t believe my eyes,” she says. Ethnic restaurants. The Magic Oven. Greens and yellows. Portuguese. She had found an unexpected second home in central Massachusetts, and, although she had been thinking of heading back home, decided then that she would stay, that she would explore the possibilities the downtown would hold for her. “That was the happiest day of my life.” She soon noticed, after making regular trips to the downtown and befriending many of its residents, that Framingham was in desperate need of more English language educators. Many spoke little English, if any at all, and had gotten used to communicating with other Lusophones, or Portuguese-speakers, living in their immediate vicinity. If she worked hard enough, she could change that, she thought. She could help people learn the language so they would be able to further their educations at local universities and community colleges, or communicate with their children’s public school teachers. When her term of service as an au pair was up, she decided to stay, and to pursue a master’s degree in English as a Second Language at Cambridge College. For her thesis, she spent dozens of hours in Framingham, as well as Marlborough and Somerville, chronicling the language deficiency issues in those communities. Her thesis, it bears repeating, was a study of Framingham State’s backyard and the residents and their children who live here. In other words, Desani is an expert on the lives, struggles and ambitions of the men and women who could very well make up the student body of FSU in the decades to come. After she graduated, and her 12-month period of legal work authorization, called Optional Practical Training, began in August of 2011, she got a job teaching ESL courses at Framingham State – a job she thought would be hers for as long as she wanted it. “In my head, I’m like, ‘I have an education. I have my master’s,” Desani says, a fat binder filled with her thesis research on the table in front of her. “I kept thinking, ‘I’m here. I’m fine.’” But after hearing “no” so many times – “‘No, we can’t do it, no, no, no,’” she says, “I just feel like I have to start over my life.” It’s a snowy Tuesday night in March, and the streets of downtown are coated with a thin, slick layer of slush. One by one, eight students, ages 25 to 54, are making their way to the third floor of a building (area undisclosed, by request), purple English textbooks and today’s homework in tow. “Foundations,” it is called – the study materials for an introductory-level ESL course. A woman going by the name Lucay, 54, cleaned five houses today, as she does every day. A man named Margins, also 54, logged a full workday on a construction site. Some are a little late – the weather made walking or driving here more difficult – but they’re here. They are learning nationalities today. “You are from Brazil, so you are?” their teacher asks. A pause. They squint their eyes, thinking. “Brazilian,” she tells them. “Brazilian,” they repeat. In a close-knit community where almost everyone with whom they interact speaks Portuguese, they haven’t had to know the word. In Framingham, just like back home, they are Brasileiro, Brasileira. Every member of the class is undocumented. For many, it’s relatively easy to get by in Framingham without learning to speak English. If new arrivals to the town speak Portuguese, they can go about their day buying groceries, ordering coffee and working jobs that don’t necessarily require communication skills – cleaning or building houses, cooking, mowing lawns. Tony, 37, a used tire salesman, picked up a few English words over the years downtown, but the language barrier has started getting in the way of his business, and he decided he finally needed to learn to speak English. “It’s not easy for me because I don’t speak it well,” he says. “I need to learn.” Saaron, a 45-year-old housecleaner, says she wants to build a better relationship with her employers. A few weeks ago, while cleaning a shelf, an ornament fell and smashed into pieces. She left her employer money to replace it, but had to use web service Google Translate to explain what happened in a handwritten note. In the future, she wants to be able to apologize in person. Nixon and Silana, who, at ages 25 and 30 are the youngest in the group, said they wanted to be able to meet English-speaking people in their new home in Framingham. Both arrived within the last year. Recently, Silana says, an English-speaking man approached her at the gym, trying to flirt with her. She misunderstood, thinking he wanted to use the machine she’d been using. Embarrassed, she ended the conversation, and the encounter felt like a missed opportunity. “I want to live here,” Silana says, through an interpreter. “How can I not learn to speak English? I love to talk!” Nixon and Silana are both hopeful they will be able to stay in Massachusetts, assimilate, make friends, and possibly go to college. Nixon is considering studying physical education, but if things don’t work out for him here, if he can’t continue to support himself in a new country, he says, learning English can help him get a job back home. Silana says being able to speak English would give her a huge competitive edge in Brazil, a country where more and more job applicants have college degrees. Margins, 54, says learning the language means protecting himself in dire situations, such as talking to the police or with angry English-speaking neighbors. “If you don’t speak English, there are a lot of problems,” he says. His classmates nod in agreement. Darilson has gotten by for the last 10 years knowing basically no English, but when his son started first grade this year, the 32-year-old decided to finally put in the effort and start taking ESL classes. “I want to learn for my son,” he says. As one of the two or three most proficient speakers in the class, he’s speaking for himself, slowly and calculatingly. “He says, ‘Dad, read my book,’ but I can’t.” At his house, his son speaks Portuguese. Darilson does not want him to forget the language of his heritage, but also, until now, Portuguese has been the only means of communication between them, and Darilson didn’t want to lose that. He will raise his son to be bilingual, and now he wants to be bilingual, too. If he wants to talk to his son’s friends and teachers, help him with his homework, read his books, he will have to. For those in Framingham who want to learn English, there are a few options. There is the Framingham Adult ESL Plus program, which runs on a lottery system. Hundreds line up for the free classes, funded through a grant from the Mass. Dept. of Education, but slots are limited. When people don’t get into those classes, they look elsewhere. Some look to other free, or cheap classes through local non-profits, some of which charge as little as $50. Some seek out private tutors, and others come to Framingham State. It was at this point in people’s lives that Desani used to intervene. As a Plus volunteer, and a well-known face downtown, she used to steer students to FSU, promising a top-notch education, even if it did cost some money – $370 per semester, for many, is a sizable financial commitment to make. But Desani used to sell the FSU program based on its merit, and on the benefits of getting a certificate of completion from an accredited state university. She would hand out informational pamphlets she translated herself from English to Portuguese – before Desani, those pamphlets were written exclusively in English. And Framingham’s residents listened. “She recruited many students,” says Rebecca Hawk, director of FSU’s ELP and community education programs. “Scores of students.” In a picture from a Boston Globe article about the ELP program, Desani is smiling, helping one of her students work through an assignment. This was the old Vanessa, the one who played music for her students, the one who snapped her fingers and danced around the classroom. The one her students called chuchu, pronounced like “shoo-shoo” – my dear. She called them chuchu, as well. The picture was taken in August, on her very last day as an instructor, before a replacement was brought in to finish teaching the remaining weeks of the class. That, Desani says, hurt more than anything – that she was not allowed to finish teaching the students she had been with since the beginning of the semester. The wounds, she says, may never heal. But in the picture, she is smiling. “The community wanted me to be there. They wanted me there to help with translations, with offices, with classes, because they felt like they belonged there. They could say, ‘This is somebody who came from the same place and is at the university. If she can be there, I can be there.’” Twelve months before administrators ran out the clock on Desani, making it illegal for her to hold her job, she was doing what she loved, with students who loved her back. After having spent so much time in their midst conducting her thesis research, Desani understood that many of her night students worked long, long hours, sometimes performing strenuous manual labor, and she needed to do something special to grab their attention, to make them want to learn. “My students work 10 hours a day, cleaning four or five houses, going to class at 7 o’clock. If I don’t do a very funny class, play music, make them jump, they will fall asleep on their desks. They are painters, they are landscapers, they are house cleaners, so I try to encourage my students. I like to make them rise and make them laugh.” Although DGCE doesn’t encourage instructors to do so, Desani also gave her students her cell phone number, and told them to call her at any time. Difficulties with their English homework, immigration issues, whatever, they could call. From her time spent as a translator at the Framingham District Court, helping to keep immigrants from signing deportation documents they couldn’t read, she understood the perils of not knowing English, or of having a limited knowledge of it in emergencies. In particular, Desani remembers the widespread panic among her students after a car accident in Milford in the summer of 2011 that, for many, changed everything. Recent FSU graduate Matt Denice was hit and killed while riding his motorcycle in August of that year, and the driver was an undocumented Ecuadorian immigrant who was heavily intoxicated and driving without a driver’s license. The horrific accident sparked local outcry against illegal immigrants in the town, and Desani’s students, many of whom also did not have driver’s licenses, saw traffic stops skyrocket. Shortly after the accident, half of her students, all of them from Milford, dropped her class, scared to brave the streets to drive to Framingham. “My students said, ‘Vanessa … a guy in a raincoat is stopping cars and asking for documents.’ They were afraid,” Desani says. “And I was the first one to say, ‘OK, don’t come to my class. I don’t want to be responsible for any deportations. I understand.’ “If they lived closer,” she adds, “I would have offered them rides.” One student, Desani says, after being arrested twice for driving without a license, just left for home, ashamed and embarrassed after being labeled a criminal. “It was terrible,” she says. These are Desani’s people, “illegal” or not. And she was determined to help them as much as she could – that is, before the rules, the laws and policies, drove her and her students apart. Desani came to FSU during a period of transition and renewal for the English language and community education programs. When former ESL Coordinator Lavonne Krishnan retired in 2008 after eight years at that post, the school spent four years hiring several other candidates to take her place, but, for one reason or another, each didn’t fit. Eventually, the school brought on Rebecca Hawk, giving her the new title of “director” of the newly merged community ed and ELP programs. Hawk says she was astonished by the predominance of the Lusophone population in Framingham and surrounding communities when she arrived here, and began overseeing attempts to reinvigorate DGCE’s efforts to recruit non-native English speakers. “‘Community education’ could mean many things,” Hawk says, and for Framingham, that meant teaching the town’s many new immigrants how to speak English, thereby preparing them for further studies – “funneling” students into night courses in business or other disciplines. In addition, renovations to the Maynard Building in Framingham Centre were well underway and the school had begun relocating classrooms and administrative offices to the new location across Route 9. DGCE was, and still is, ramping up spending on outreach – Greenberg says last year alone, FSU spent nearly $10,000 on print and radio ads, postcards and handouts. For three days a week, Desani taught morning and evening classes in the McCarthy Center, putting in extra, unpaid hours working late in her office to put together outreach materials. As a guest on AM 650, a locally operated Portuguese-language radio station, she would field questions from residents. “You have to stop watching soap operas and come to school!” she would say, playfully attempting to tease listeners out of their comfort zones. “When I met Vanessa,” Hawk says, “I saw that she had this passion to connect with the community.” Desani had been with the program for just a month, but had big ideas, passion and a strong work ethic. The timing, back then, seemed perfect. “The first task at hand was to make our ELP program more accessible to the community,” Hawk says. The word “accessible” is an important one, she says, because crafting programs and making courses “available” to students is not enough – not for those who speak no English at all, or who simply have not considered studying the language at FSU because no one has made the effort to recruit them. Before Desani and Hawk arrived at Framingham State, Portuguese-speaking residents would call, curious about the program, but no one was on staff who could speak with them in their own language. “Sorry,” ELP personnel would say. “No Portuguese.” Today, no one on the DGCE staff is fluent in Spanish or Portuguese, and no one is making claims of being “bilingual.” Hawk herself can speak some Portuguese, but not enough that she could conduct phone conversations confidently. Desani could communicate freely and easily with community members, building a relationship it would be nearly impossible for other ELP staff to replicate. Having Desani on staff meant having an employee who was the triple threat Hawk needed: she was bilingual, she was trained as an educator and she undertook a proactive, community advocacy-oriented approach to her job. In Framingham, Desani says, “I thought, ‘I need to reach my community. How am I going to do this? I have to communicate in Portuguese so people can know more about the university.’ So that’s what I did.” To Hawk and Desani, being an ESL teacher is about more than offering instruction on how to speak English. Much more. Desani first learned to speak the language while studying at São Paulo, but instead of actually learning English, she says, she learned something else entirely – how not to teach a language. Her professor refused to speak Portuguese in the classroom, insisting that she and her classmates learn in total immersion. “I couldn’t help but cry,” she says. “I said to my mom, ‘I’m not coming back. I couldn’t understand a word he said.’” She likens that classroom in southern Brazil to the ones at Framingham State. Here, though, it isn’t that the professors won’t speak their students’ language, be it Portuguese or Spanish, Chinese or German. They just can’t. “That’s a big problem,” Desani says. “Especially if you think about community education.” After Desani’s termination, Hawk says, many of her students left as well, some of them vowing to follow their teacher to her next job. “It was a severe drop-off when she left. … I’d say we’re in a period of recovery from that.” “She was dynamic,” she says, “and she filled a niche that is very difficult to fill. … Not having her here is a tremendous loss. It’s a loss for the community and for us, actually.” To this day, Hawk still hears complaints from the community about the ELP losing Desani – “that still comes out in the dialogues,” she says. “I tell them, ‘It’s a very difficult decision, and I’m sorry it didn’t happen as well as it could have, but we still have a good program, and we can still teach you English, so please come here.” She has been trying to maintain Desani’s connections to the community in her absence. A Portuguese-speaking FSU underclassman from Brazil started working in the office on a volunteer basis this semester – explaining the ELP program to locals in their own language, just as Desani did. Greenberg says DGCE is in the process of hiring a long-term bilingual employee, and will begin interviewing applicants next week. In the meantime, Hawk has even been making guest appearances on AM 650 and making the case for FSU over the airwaves, just as Desani did. But it isn’t the same, she says. She can only speak with the help of a translator, and can’t connect with listeners based on the shared experience of learning English after arriving here from South America. The distinction is simple: like many downtown residents, Desani came from Brazil to a foreign country, and worked for years to learn the language. Hawk didn’t. Desani can speak from experience about the difference learning English can make as a non-American. Hawk can’t. “The same place you’re sitting now,” Desani used to tell her students, “I was there, learning English here, like you are doing.” Of the 300 ELP students enrolled last semester, 51 percent spoke Portuguese as their primary language. This semester, Hawk expects that figure to swell to 60 percent or more. This is the community with which she is working, and she wishes something could be done to bring Desani back to help meet its needs. “It is complicated and I understand the school’s policy, but sometimes a need arises and a policy needs to be assessed. The world that we live in is becoming more and more global,” she says, adding, “sometimes exceptions need to be made in anticipation of what the need could be.” Less than a mile away from FSU, thousands of Portuguese-speaking residents are listening to their radios, hanging out in bakeries, working long hours babysitting or doing manual labor around town, and Hawk wants to help them learn to speak English, to become part- or even full-time students at Framingham State. But now, she has to do it without Desani. “From the university’s standpoint,” Hawk says, “I think it’s a missed opportunity.” FSU is not the only employer which has rejected Desani due to her immigration status over the last few months. She says she has probably been to interviews at a dozen colleges and universities – Tufts, Bentley, Northeastern among them – and each has progressed in what is now a predictable pattern: the conversation will go well, the interviewer will seem impressed and will sometimes even ask for her availability, will ask how soon she can start teaching. Then, she breaks it to them. “Well, here it comes,” she has started saying out loud. “Immigrant.” “Visa.” “Thirty-five hundred dollars.” Then, the interview ends, the interviewer apologizes, says there is nothing he or she can do, and Desani goes home. Often, she prays. “God helps me, but I have to move, too. Its hard for me because I have been waiting for something, and I don’t know what to do.” She stubbornly refuses to let her spirit be broken, although she isn’t sure how much longer she can do this – how much longer she can live in limbo. “I feel that something is going to work out, but right now I have no idea,” she says, seemingly a bit surprised by how pessimism has started creeping up on her. “You know when you’re completely lost? I don’t know what to do. ” She pauses. “Something is going to work. I don’t think things happen just because. Something will work.” She pauses again. “But some days I feel like I should just pack up all my stuff and go back. But that’s not typical of me.” Just after New Year’s Day, Desani felt lumps in her chest, and fearing she might have breast cancer, saw a specialist. Her diagnosis? High levels of stress had caused some severe tightening in her pectoral muscles. “The lady doing the test, she said to me, ‘I know what your problem is. You have immigration pains. You have immigration pains in your chest.’” To this day, Desani still has trouble sleeping. She wakes up with anxiety about what the future will hold, clinging to the hope that God will intervene and make something happen. Her mother lives in Brazil, along with the rest of her family, and they all seem to think she should just admit defeat and return home. Either that or go back to school and get a degree in science or engineering – the kinds of degrees that lead to visas in a country where employers are falling over themselves to attract the world’s top STEM workers. But Desani wants to teach, and she wants to be an advocate for the disadvantaged, and above all, she wants to do it here. “I don’t know why,” she says. “I wish it was different. I wish I could be a doctor. I decided to come here for one year to learn English. It has been six years. Why? Is it because I like the weather? No. Is it because I like to be alone without my family? No.” It is because she is passionate about teaching, about providing Framingham’s Portuguese-speaking residents with hope and opportunity to succeed when their futures, like hers, can be uncertain – at the whim of a system that can feel designed to make them fail. But until she can find some way out of limbo, some lucky break, it seems as if no one on this campus, in this state or in this country will let her do it. They can’t, they say. Those are the rules.
- Film review: Park-Chan Wook’s ‘Stoker’ just short of an evil masterpiece
By Michael B. Murphy Editorial Staff Korean filmmaker Park Chan-wook’s English-language debut “Stoker” is somewhat of an odd duck. As a meditation on the inherent evil that resides in all of us – how this seed of evil can be nurtured and encouraged by another – “Stoker” is a beautifully macabre experience, filled with rich imagery and symbolism that, no doubt, make it a worthy addition to the pantheon of Chan-wook’s films (e.g. “Sympathy for Mr. Vengeance,” “Oldboy,” “Lady Vengeance” and “I’m a Cyborg, But That’s OK”). Unfortunately, its script (written by former “Prison Break” star Wentworth Miller) often works against the films powerful visual storytelling, undermining it with several predictable revelations and some odd characterizations that will compromise the suspension of disbelief of many of its audience. Evil is a common theme found throughout Chan-wook’s filmography and no where is it more prevalent than in “Stoker” There are multiple murders committed throughout the film and they are often ghastly. With one exception, none of the killings are done in self-defense – they are lustful executions. One female character masturbates in a shower, reliving the image of a young man’s neck being snapped with a belt. Many viewers of the film will find this too appalling and off-putting to be able to see the larger message that Chan-wook is attempting to convey about the seeds of evil that can blossom in all of us. The story focuses on Mia Wasikowska’s character, 18-year old India Stoker, a meek and sheltered young woman with porcelain skin, who is grieving the loss of her father, Richard (played in flashbacks by Dermot Mulroney), who was just killed in a mysterious automobile accident. Richard’s death prompts a visit from his brother Charlie, an uncle India never knew existed. Very quickly the family’s world is turned upside down as Charlie moves in and begins seducing both India and her emotionally unbalanced mother, Evelyn (Nicole Kidman who gives an great, icy performance). As we get to know more about Charlie – he has just returned from a lengthy European business trip, he informs the family – we can immediately sense something is not quite right about him. Early on in the film, the loyal housemaid, Mrs. McGarrick, is seen shouting at Charlie, clearly not happy to see him return and inect himself into the Stoker family dynamics. Later, Charlie’s Aunt Gina visits and attempts to warn the mother and daughter about their new housemate. It becomes quite evident early on it’s India who Charlie is ultimately trying to seduce. He sees an evilness inside of her that resembles his own and uses his good looks and charm to bring about a sexual and murderous awakening in his niece. Charlie begins to ensnare India in his violent web, making her complicit in his murderous actions and, you know what? India seems to love every minute of it. As mentioned earlier, the main problem with “Stoker” is its script. Chan-wook does a wonderful job ratcheting up the suspense at all the right moments, masterfully juggling several taut and suspenseful intercutting scenes that all build into a crazed, blood-soaked crescendo. However, the big reveals are never that shocking, most are predictable, and no matter how damn good Chan-wook is at building up to the film’s payoff scenes (and he is that damn good), they are, in effect, flaccid and lacking the punch needed in a psychological thriller like this because the script shows most of its cards to soon. It’s because of this that Stoker works best as a symbolic visual representation of how evil is attracted to evil – how the evil in all of us can be brought to the surface by the most unlikeliest of sources. Unfortunately, because of its script, “Stoker” never quite reaches the heights that it should, given its exceptionally talented cast and director, but despite all this, one cannot walk away from this film and not have a visceral reaction – which is something all quality art should evoke.
- Wobbly tiles in front of McCarthy Center being replaced
By Michael B. Murphy Assistant News Editor Even after a three-day overtime shift shoveling, plowing and salting the Framingham State campus, it looks like Facilities’ Nemo clean-up efforts are still not over. In addition to dumping nearly 30 inches of snow on FSU, the historic storm’s frigid, icy conditions caused some concrete tiles located in front of the McCarthy Center to become dislodged and dangerous to walk on, Facilities Director Warren Fairbanks said Tuesday. The area has ben roped off with caution tape and orange pylons to keep students from stepping on the wobbly tiles on their way inside the building until they can be fixed. As of Wednesday afternoon, though, the caution tape has been detached from the cones, and many students have been walking through the damaged area. Fairbanks said the support for the tiles has been “displaced” and, because of that, they are “going to rock every time once you step on [them].” The original installer of the tiles, Fairbanks said, has been called into “basically reset the entire deck.” Fairbanks estimated the repairs could take on to two weeks and will cost “in the $5,000 t0 $10,000 range. What we expect might happened is the roof drain underneath the tiles … probably froze during the storm and that pushed up, from underneath, the tiles,” he said. “It seemed to happen right after the storm.” While an inconvenience, Fairbanks said the repairs are a project that had to be completed eventually and will allow Facilities to “clean out the roof drain and clean out the debris” as well as “see if the integrity of the roof is still good. “We had been thinking about doing it because every now and then we’ll get a tile that would rock. … We were thinking about waiting until the [summer] break, but I think that will be too long so we will have him get it done as soon as [the installer] has the time to,” Fairbanks said. The tiled entrance to the McCarthy Center, installed about eight years ago, covers the roof to the Dining Commons, explained Fairbanks. “None of the tiles cracked – they’re still good,” he added. “That kind of surprised me, but that’s a good sign.” Sophomore Criminology major Tori Sepavich said she is unhappy with the progress of the tiles being replaced. “I think it’s pretty ridiculous that they haven’t fixed them yet and simply highlighted the problem with orange cones and yellow tape. They have seemingly just elft that stuff there and people are still tripping,” Sepavich said. Senior Communication Arts major Samantha Solimini was angered as well. “I think it’s dangerous that they haven’t been fixed yet, not onfly for the students but for the number of elderly faculty members and visitors who are also tripping on them and are risking being severly injured. It’s such a high volume, high traffic area of campus and people are tripping constantly. There’s no excuse for them not being fixed yet,” Solimini said. Junior Criminology major Jasmin Hathaway-Houston said she fell and hurt her foot on the tiles. “I stepped on it wrong and I sprained my ankle. It hurt like hell,” she said. Hathaway-Houston said a doctor had told her the ankle was sprained and that she is fine now “but it hurt for like a week.”
- One in four students have driven drunk
By Michael B. Murphy Assistant News Editor By Alex Shuman Editorial Staff By Cristina Valente Staff Writer An unscientific survey of 400 FSU students, conducted by The Gatepost from Nov. 15 through Nov. 20, found that over one-fourth of students have driven drunk at least once. A majority want a “no questions asked” transportation system on campus. When asked how often students had operated a motor vehicle under the influence of alcohol, 111 of the 400 students surveyed answered at least once and 289 answered never. Dean of Students Melinda Stoops was alarmed upon hearing that students do not always use a designated driver. “If [students] are going off campus and they know they are going to be drinking, I would encourage them to discuss it beforehand instead of at the end being stuck and saying, ‘Oh, who’s okay to drive?’” When asked whether they had been a passenger in a vehicle driven by a drunk driver at least once, 224 of the 400 students surveyed answered “yes.” “That’s really concerning,” said Stoops. “They know the risk involved. My guess is that it’s not a lack of knowledge. The problem, obviously, is when people are intoxicated, they don’t make good choices. At the time, their decision-making process was probably impaired by the alcohol in their system. “It goes back to, ‘How did they find themselves in this situation where they felt like they had no other choice than to get in a car with an impaired driver or to drive themselves?’” Stoops asked. In 2009, according to AlcoholAlert. com, 33 percent of people killed in alcohol-related accidents were not driving the vehicle – they were either passengers in the vehicle or non-occupants. Students want transport system for potential drunk drivers When asked whether having a “no questions asked” transportation system back to campus on Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights would be beneficial to the FSU community, 379 of 400 students surveyed answered “yes.” SGA President Hannah Bruce said she recognizes the need for school-sponsored measures to help curb drunk driving. “We need to recognize that students are going to drink, so why not promote safety rather than expecting students to refrain from drinking? It’s an unrealistic expectation.” Freshman James Chege, a chemistry major, said, “I think people drink and drive because they think it’s their only way to get home. If there was a way to get home without having to drive, it would be a lot safer and save lives.” Senior English major Emily Zarnoch said, “A safe ride is a great idea. Students will be much safer and I believe many students would use it after Ashley Donahue’s death.” Donahue was a junior communication arts major when she was killed in an alleged drunk driving accident on Badger Road in Framingham in December of 2011. Donahue was a passenger in a car operated by fellow student Brooke Uttley, who had offered to drive several students back to Framingham State after an off-campus party. According to police reports, Uttley had been driving around 60 mph when her car veered off the road and smashed into a telephone pole, ejecting Donahue out the vehicle’s back window. The posted speed limit on the road is 25. Police at the scene determined Uttley’s blood alcohol level to be .10. The legal limit is .08. Uttley is set to face trial at the Middlesex District Court in June, where she will reportedly plead guilty to charges of vehicular homicide, operating under the influence and driving to endanger. Uttley has withdrawn from the university. One survey respondent said, “In light of recent events, I think [a “no questions asked” transportation system] is a good idea.” Car crashes are the leading cause of death among teens and young adults and one-third of these deaths are alcohol related, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. In 2011, 9,878 people were killed in drunk driving-related accidents. To better put this statistic into perspective – every 53 minutes, someone is killed as a result of drunk driving. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, people between the ages of 21 to 25 are most likely to drink and drive. In 2010, persons in this age group were responsible for 34 percent of all fatal drunk driving accidents. Stoops said, “Drinking and driving is a critical area of safety. … I’m certainly not opposed to working with students and looking into it.” However, a school-sponsored transportation system would essentially violate FSU’s alcohol policy, which states it is against the rules to be on campus while intoxicated, said Stoops. “It’s a challenge and there is no perfect solution. There isn’t something that we could put into place without creating a gray area.” Even though such a transportation system may not be possible, Stoops said she hopes that by this time next year, “at the very least we will be able to have a RamCash system in taxis. “We wanted to work with a couple of the local cab companies to set up a system where students could use RamCash for rides back to campus after hours. The snag we ran into was the technology.” ID scanners used around campus and at places like CVS and Papa Gino’s are only available at stationary locations, and the RamCash system has not yet been made portable. “The technology doesn’t exist for the company that we use,” said Stoops “But, on the positive side, they think that by next academic year, they’ll have a system developed. “There’s no way to do it right now. It’s something that we are definitely looking into,” she added. Laura Stagliola, a junior history major, said, “I think it’s a good idea in theory, but I don’t think many students always have RamCash – my mom doesn’t put RamCash on my card anymore, and I really only use it to do laundry.” Siobhan McLernon, a senior communication arts major, said, “If taxi rides were discounted for students, then I think it would be used a lot more. … Students are going to drink regardless of the rules, and to give them the option to have a safe ride back to campus without having to pay a lot for a taxi could save lives.” FSU used to subsidize taxi vouchers for students, but ended the program in the fall of 2012. At the same time, administrators purchased a second shuttle as part of the Ram Tram program, which provides rides to a few nearby hot spots such as Shoppers World and the Natick Mall. Salem State junior Kyle Rufo said Salem Taxi offers $5 taxi rides to students with an SSU ID. “I use it every time I go to the bars downtown.” Some local high schools provide this service as well. Julie Briggs, a physical education teacher at Malden High School, has had a longstanding agreement with the owner of the Malden Taxi Company. This agreement states that if a Malden High student needs a ride home, “whether they were drunk and couldn’t call their parents or they were on a date gone bad and didn’t feel safe,” they can call Malden Taxi, show them their school ID and a driver will bring them home, said Briggs. It was a “‘Don’t ask, don’t tell’ policy. I did it with my kids at home and I brought it to the kids at school,” she said. Briggs was the advisor of SADD (Students Against Destructive Decisions) at Malden High School for ten years. “I wanted to take care of the Malden kids. “Kids are going to drink – 18 to 22 are the stupidest years of a person’s life, but there is no excuse for getting in a car with a drunk driver,” said Briggs. Stoops said FSU administrators are doing more to promote safety and good decision-making. This year, FSU signed up for a service called AlcoholEdu – an online alcohol awareness and education module that must be completed by incoming freshmen before the first day of class. “It’s more in-depth and it’s personalized,” said Stoops. “Even if you are a non-drinker, you can still benefit from AlcoholEdu. For example, it talks about recognizing the symptoms of alcohol poisoning in others.” The AlcoholEdu program is also open to parents. “They can take a parent version, and hopefully, people will come to FSU having already talked about [alcohol]. “We are planning to use the results for programming efforts,” said Stoops. “It will be opened up to all students in the fall and it provides good education for all students.” In addition to AlcoholEdu, Stoops is also head of the Live Safe committee that was started last spring. The committee consists of about ten members, both students and faculty. The Live Safe committee discusses “promoting safe choices for students,” said Stoops, which could include topics ranging from drinking and driving to wearing a seat belt to not walking alone at night in unfamiliar places. “We try to encourage students to make good choices that will keep them safe and not make choices that could put them at risk. “We want you to have a great experience here at FSU, which involves inside and outside the classroom. We want you to have fun, we want you to go out and we want you to be safe.” Students disagree with zero tolerance alcohol policy, want 21-plus dorm The crux of the student drinking issue, for many of the students surveyed, was FSU’s zero tolerance alcohol policy – a policy that many surveyed believe leads students to act more secretively and more dangerously. The FSU alcohol policy, found in the 2012-2013 Ram student handbook, states that any resident student found to be under the influence or in possession of alcohol will receive a one-week restriction from all residence halls and a one-week restriction from participating in any school-sponsored events for the first offense. Some students who violate the policy can pay a $175 fine to avoid suspension from residence halls. Successful completion of an alcohol education and assessment program at the FSU’s Health Center and a fine increasing with offenses is also part of all sanctions. The punishment’s increase with a second offense and a third violation can result in a 16-week suspension from the university. When asked if they agreed with FSU’s alcohol policy, 215 of the 400 students surveyed answered “no” and 100 students answered “yes.” Eightyfive students said they were “not sure.” Many student survey respondents indicated they believe that FSU’s dry campus policy, ironically, endangers students more than would a policy that was less strict. “I think if FSU got rid of the no alcohol policy, the community would act more safely with regard to drinking instead of having to drink in secret,” said an anonymous survey taker. Senior Samantha Clementi, a fashion major, said she believes the zero-tolerance policy should be lifted because the harsh penalties from getting caught drinking have led many students to commit risky behavior to avoid being caught. “I don’t think it helps,” Clementi said. “People go out and don’t think about getting back to campus, or think they’ll get in trouble, so they drive with a friend or get themselves in a bad situation. It’s not the only factor, but I think [incidents] like that would be reduced” were it not for the dry campus policy. Another survey respondent said, “People should not be afraid to call [campus police] for fear of getting in trouble if someone needs medical help/ attention.” Psychology major Marc Amedee, a sophomore, believes the repercussions for violating the university’s alcohol policy are too punitive, as students are punished harshly after first offenses. “It’s such a hassle if you get caught,” Amedee said, “and you have to complete online courses and go to meetings. I’d say 99.1 percent of students would want this place to be a wet campus.” One survey respondent, who self identified as a non-drinker, believes the FSU policy is unfair to students, many of whom are of legal drinking age. “Anyone over 21 shouldn’t have to lose their privilege of drinking if they are mature and old enough to drink,” the student said. Junior business administration major Nate Labreche said he got in trouble with FSUPD for having an unopened 12-pack of beer in his car while parked in the Maple 1 lot. “I was 22 at the time and stopped at the liquor store before class, left the beer in the car during class, and got in trouble with [campus police] after class. This should not be considered eligible for getting in trouble,” said Labreche. Dean Stoops said she recognizes that the zero-tolerance policy has caused many students to have a “students against the administration” mindset. “It’s like a ‘we want to drink and you won’t let us’-type of thing,” Stoops said. “The bottom line is, I’m not telling students of age never to drink – that’s not what I’m about, and that’s not what my message personally is.” When asked whether they believe FSU should provide a 21-plus residence hall where alcohol would be permitted, 346 students responded “yes” and 54 said “no.” Previous Gatepost surveys have found similarly strong support for a 21-plus dorm. A 2006 survey conducted by The Gatepost, which found that 162 of 200 FSU seniors would support a 21-plus dorm. A 2007 survey found that 145 of 200 seniors supported such a residence. Having spoken to many staff members who worked at FSU before it became a dry campus, Stoops said the wet campus environment was non-conducive to students’ learning and safety. “I’ve heard that, prior to the change, we had an environment here where not only was there heavy alcohol use, but a lot of disruption to the college environment at the time – student life, damage in the residence halls and things you would expect to have with drinking on campus,” Stoops said. Years ago, of-age students were given the option of living in Linsley Hall, a “wet” dorm where they were allowed to drink. The residence, on the opposite side of Adams Road, is the most secluded dorm on campus. Linsley became a “dry” dorm in 1999. FSU used to have an on-campus pub located where the Ram’s Den Grille is currently, where students could host events and watch sports games on TV. Administrators, under the leadership of then-President Helen Heineman, began slowly phasing out usage of the pub starting in the fall of 1999, when the pub only served alcohol Mondays and Fridays. After the pub was renovated in the fall of 2000, McCarthy’s served alcohol only sporadically, usually for senior class events, and was closed for good a few years ago. Even after the bar stopped carrying alcohol, McCarthy’s remained a popular spot for hosting events such as open mics and poetry slams, and continued to sport a long bar counter on its right side. McCarthy’s was renovated into a dining location in 2010. Of the 10 schools in the Massachusetts state university and UMass systems, only two – UMass Amherst and UMass Dartmouth – currently have oncampus bars. Almost half of FSU students drink on campus Although the alcohol policy clearly states that students cannot be under the influence or in possession of alcohol while on campus, many students said they have found ways to bring the contraband onto campus and into their dorms. Students surveyed were asked how often they drink on campus. Of the 400 students surveyed, 100 answered “one to three days a month” and 73 students answered between “one to three days a week.” Eight students answered that they drink on campus “four or more days a week.” The majority of the students surveyed, 219, said they “never” drink on campus. When asked to rate the level of difficulty of bringing alcohol into residence halls, 97 out of the 400 students surveyed answered “very easy” and 139 students answered “somewhat easy.” Only 49 students answered it was “difficult” to sneak alcohol past RAs and 115 students said they’ve “never attempted.” Catie Andris, a sophomore English major and student desk attendant, said she could not speak of incidences where students were caught bringing alcohol into residence halls, but explained the search is limited to students’ book bags or purses. “We have residents open [bags and purses], and then we have this wooden stick sort of thing that we poke around in the bag with,” Andris said. “If there’s a sweatshirt or laptop in the bag keeping us from seeing all of the bag’s contents, we may ask the resident to remove said objects.” Andris said RAs and student desk attendants are not allowed to touch, with their hands, any personal belongings of students inside their purses or book bags due to privacy rights. When asked if bag checks are conducted randomly or every time a student enters a residence hall, Andris said, “Everybody [gets checked], 24 hours a day. Everyone’s bag. Seven days a week.” Despite these efforts, FSU students claim to have found ways to bring alcohol into their rooms. Nicole Davignon, a senior English major, said, “Oh yeah, I’ve seen other students do it all the time. Students have gotten so sneaky about it though, so it’s harder to figure out how they’re doing it.” Students say FSU’s policy more strict than other schools’ When asked if students believe FSU’s alcohol policy is more or less strict than those at other state universities, 303 of the 400 students said they believe Framingham State’s is more strict. Fifty-three students said it is equally strict, 9 students said it is less strict and 36 students are not familiar with other schools’ policies. Alcohol policies at other schools in the state university and UMass systems vary, as do the sanctions that come with violating them. FSU and Worcester State are the only two fully dry public campuses in the state. Salem, Bridgewater and MCLA are dry, with on-campus wet dorms or apartments. At Fitchburg, Westfield, UMass Dartmouth and MassArt, students over 21 can drink in their dorms. UMass Amherst residence halls have designated 21-plus floors where drinking is allowed. At UMass Lowell, only two of eight dorms are dry. UMass Boston is a commuter school, which does not have residence halls. School administrators at all wet campuses set guidelines for the amounts of alcohol that can be stored in each room, as well as other measures aimed at reducing binge drinking, such as banning beer funnels, kegs and ice luges. Sanctions for alcohol violations at Massachusetts’ public schools vary. Framingham is the only school which suspends students from res halls for first alcohol-related offenses. School policy dictates that resident students who violate the alcohol policy are suspended for one week from living in or visiting dorms and participating in campus events. A second violation gets residents a five-week suspension, 16 weeks for a third. At Westfield State, students are required to complete 10 hours of community service for a first offense, are suspended from housing for one semester for a second, and receive another one-semester housing suspension for a third. UMass Dartmouth students are also required to give 10 hours of “community restitution” for a first violation. For second offenses, students are required to complete more hours of service in addition to other sanctions. Third offenses lead to suspension or dismissal from their res hall or from the school. At Salem State, first-time violators are placed under “residential review,” while second-time violators receive a one-year suspension from residence halls. A third violation results in suspension from the university. A first violation at Worcester State could result either in a written warning or one semester of probation, depending on the situation. A second violation, however, could result in a res hall suspension of up to one year, while a third could mean expulsion either from dorms or from the university itself. Bridgewater State students who violate the school’s alcohol policy might also just receive a written warning, but a second offense leads to a res hall suspension of unspecified length, and a third offense could lead to university suspension. After first offenses at Fitchburg State, students have to complete an education program and pay a small fine. A second violation leads to a semester-long suspension from res halls and a third leads to university suspension for one semester. At UMass Amherst, first-time violators receive two years of housing probation and two more violations lead to permanent housing removal. UMass Lowell students receive a written warning for their first offense, followed by a year of probation and removal from housing for second and third offenses, respectively. Violations at MassArt, according to an online policy outline, are met with unspecified “disciplinary sanctions” handed down by a Hearing Officer. A third offense for underage drinking, though, can result in expulsion. All schools require students to complete some version of an alcohol education course for most violations. Three-fourths of students drink off campus Students surveyed were asked how often they consume alcohol off campus. 149 out of the 400 students surveyed answered between “one to three days a month,” 73 students answered between “one to three days a week,” 21 students answered “four or more days a week,” and 107 students said they never drink off campus. When asked how often students attend off-campus parties where alcohol is served, 116 of the 400 students surveyed answered “once or twice a month,” 67 students answered “a few times a month,” 76 students answered “often,” and 141 students responded that they never attend off-campus parties. A majority of students, 254 of the 400 students surveyed, said they drank “to socialize,” two students answered they drank due to “peer pressure,” 64 students said they drank “to get drunk.” Five students answered they drank “to avoid/escape something” and 75 students said they drink for “other” reasons. Some students who answered “other” said they drink because they enjoy the taste of alcohol, and that it helps them relax. Students surveyed were asked how much they drink on average in one sitting. 122 of the 400 students surveyed answered “one to two drinks,” 138 students answered “three to four drinks,” 51 students answered “five to six drinks,” 49 students answered “more than six drinks” and 41 students answered they do not drink. Health and Wellness Program Coordinator Judy Grob-Whiting said she was not surprised by the survey results overall. According to Grob-Whiting, in 2011, Health Services conducted a “Core” survey, which is used nationwide, about alcohol use among students. The results showed the average student believes 98 percent of the student body drinks alcohol. The actual number of students who said they do drink is 73 percent, according to GrobWhiting. “They are thinking ‘Oh, everybody drinks,’ when in actuality, three-fourths are drinking, and they are drinking quite responsibly,” said Grob-Whiting. From the “Core” survey, she concluded that the average student who drinks has only three drinks per week. “The perception out there is that everybody is drinking vast quantities, but that is not true. In reality, people are drinking moderately or not at all.” She said that this perception is prevalent due to the fact that binge drinkers are “more visible” than conservative and moderate drinkers. The Gatepost’s survey found that the majority of students said they consumed four or fewer drinks in one sitting. “That does not meet the definition of binge drinking, which is a good thing,” she said. The CDC defines “binge drinking” as “when men consume 5 or more drinks, and when women consume 4 or more drinks, in about 2 hours.” Grob-Whiting works with students who have violated FSU’s alcohol policy, and said she notices a large number of students in the mandatory course are students under 21, particularly freshmen. “They [freshmen] may not have had a whole lot of experience [drinking] prior to college … with the perception that everyone drinks in college,” she said. “Usually, students 21-plus drink more responsibly. They go out and they drink in a very safe way. “I see the students who do violate the alcohol policy, and some are students who rarely drink, or drink moderately, but one time, they did the wrong thing,” said Grob-Whiting.
- Gatepost Editorial: Framingham State’s Big Lie
By The Gatepost Editorial Board For years now, school administrators have branded FSU a “dry campus.” Framingham State students, they have told state agencies, parents and collegeready high schoolers, live and study in an environment that is alcohol-free. This policy has helped to ensure that we can focus on our schoolwork and avoid the dangers associated with drinking too much, or drinking underage, they have said. Being a dry campus has made us safer, they have said. This is Framingham State’s Big Lie – one told over and over again, even as the tragic death of student Ashley Donahue in an accident allegedly caused by a drunk driver and startling evidence to the contrary indicate the opposite. Because of the Big Lie, there is not a safe place to drink on campus. Many students feel less likely to get in trouble if they drink off of school grounds, and thus eventually have to drive back to their dorms, sometimes under the influence. According to The Gatepost survey featured in this issue, one in four of us have done just that. More than half of us have accepted a ride from someone else who has. It is common knowledge across campus that Framingham State students drink alcohol, be it in their dorm rooms, at nearby bars or at their friends’ apartments and houses. Anyone who looks closely enough at FSU campus life knows that the school’s Big Lie does not accurately represent reality. According to Framingham State policy, of age students are not allowed to drink on campus, but they do. According to the policy, of age students are not even allowed to come back to their residence halls with alcohol in their systems, but, as long as students aren’t obviously, dangerously drunk, student desk attendants are constantly looking the other way. Framingham State students are drinking, just like their “wet campus” peers. And everyone knows it. The Big Lie is a deliberate denial of reality – one designed to benefit the school, not its students. Administrators, presumably, perpetuate the Lie to boost the university’s reputation for offering a safer, less distracting environment than other institutions across the state. But wouldn’t a reputation for being responsible, for putting student safety above all else and for taking proactive measures to curb driving under the influence, be a better reputation to have than one based on a Big Lie? In the eyes of administrators, is being “dry” more important than being safe? The Gatepost’s recommendations for possible programs to help promote safe alcohol use are not new. Nor are they without precedent and working models elsewhere. Framingham State needs a “no questions asked” transportation service, which would offer students a safe ride home if they have had too much to drink, or if their drivers have. It needs a 21-plus dorm, similar to those at nearly every other public university in the state, where of age students can consume alcohol responsibly without running the risk of being booted off campus. It would benefit greatly by having an oncampus pub – like the one at UMass Dartmouth, or like the now-defunct McCarthy’s, which shut its doors on the FSU campus a few years ago – where students could meet up without having to arrange for a ride to or from, and where those with little experience drinking alcohol could learn to do so responsibly in a safe environment. But as long as administrators insist on maintaining the “dry campus” policy – as long as they insist on maintaining Framingham State’s Big Lie – we will never have any of those things. FSU students overwhelmingly do not support the “dry campus” policy, and a majority are ignoring it, anyway. FSU’s motto, the one emblazoned everywhere, is “Live to the Truth.” For the sake of students’ safety, it is time administrators start following it, and admit that the status quo is not working.
- Music review: Tomahawk’s “Oddfellows”
By Michael B. Murphy Editorial Staff If fans of the alternative supergroup Tomahawk have concerns about the future of the band after their 2007 misstep “Anonymous” – an album comprised of reworked Native American musical compositions – well, they need not worry. The band’s fourth LP, “Oddfellows,” sees Tomahawk – comprised of Mike Patton, vocalist of Faith No More, Jesus Lizard guitarist Duane Denison, former Helmet drummer John Stanier and Mr. Bungle bassist Trevor Dunn – return to form with a collection of 13 moody tracks that hearken back to their self-titled 2001 debut. Album opener and eponymous track “Oddfellows” finds Patton dramatically belting out the lines “They call us odd fellows / We’re dancing on the gallows / Who will judge you tomorrow?” over Stanier’s deliberately robotic drum beats, while Denison’s guitar riffs lunge forward at you like a pissed off, hissing viper. As the song ends in a dizzying crescendo of noodling guitar lines and Patton’s rapid-fire whispers, Tomahawk will have listeners wondering if the band has released its most disturbing and impenetrable album to date. This would certainly be the case if not for tracks “Typhoon” and “Stone Letter,” the latter of which sounds like it could almost be at home on a Foo Fighters or Queens of the Stone Age album. While perhaps a bit too aggressive for most mainstream rock listeners’ ears, “Stone Letter” shows Tomahawk embracing Patton’s more pop-friendly vocals from his days in Faith No More, which allows the band to just plain rock out, albeit on their own unconventional terms. This is the most fun the band has ever sounded. While not as sonically diverse as their second album, 2003’s “Mit Gas,” “Oddfellows” is the bands most cohesive album to date. Every song sounds as if it belongs on the same album – a quality that can’t be said for “Mit Gas.” “Oddfellows” slithers quietly, yet menacingly, like a mean dog during the tracks “I.O.U.” and “A Thousand Suns” before lurching into a violent seizure of frenzied barked vocals and guttural howls on “White Hats/Black Hats.” Sometimes, the tempo changes drastically within just one song, like “Rise Up Dirty Waters,” which coasts along quietly with crisp finger-snaps and a bass line that could make itself at home on a jazzy soundtrack inspired by a Mickey Spillane novel. This breezy coolness fails to last when Denison’s propulsive guitar rises above the rhythm section and Patton begins to maniacally sermonize the listener like a possessed pastor who is speaking in tongues. This back and forth between quiet and loud never abates until the album’s conclusion, but, thankfully, it never veer too far off into either direction. It’s perhaps Patton and his versatile tool kit of vocal techniques that prevents “Oddfellows” from ever becoming cannibalized by its yin and yanging of tempos and moods. He almost sounds downright happy and playful as the music becomes loud and dangerous, as heard on standout track “Southpaw.” It’s when the mood gets quiet and spacious, like on “Baby Let’s Play,” that Patton’s vocals become their most sinister. In “Bone-dry,” he hauntingly singsongs over the sounds of a disturbed lullaby. Those looking for a comfortable listening experience should steer clear of Tomahawk’s latest, but those who are up for a challenging rock album should look no further.
- Elaine Rubenoff awarded first place at the Annual Juried Exhibition
By Sara Silvestro Assistant Arts & Features Editor Since last Wednesday, Framingham State University students have been seen wandering into the Mazmanian Gallery, attracted to the liveliness of the artwork. Most students have their headphones in their ears, feet crossed and take their time looking at the maze of sculptures and the visual décor lining the walls. Yesterday, the artists of the honored pieces that were featured in this year’s Annual Juried Exhibition mingled with the FSU community, giving them faces and voices to connect the admired artwork. The Annual Juried Exhibition awarded senior Elaine Rubenoff as first place for her portrait of herself as a young child, which incorporates childhood flashbacks of pure happiness. The portrait is of a fair blond child, accompanied by a brown teddy bear, with her hands wrapped securely around a bowl. The canvas is cropped just below her eyes. Rubenoff’s motives were to crop the portrait in a way that would encourage viewers to look at this portrait and perceive their own childhood memories. In essence, painting is an outlet for Rubenoff and a gateway to inner memories of childhood and a release of emotions. “I lost my father about a year and a half ago,” said Rubenoff. “He passed away from cancer. Ever since then, I have been searching for satisfaction in life through these paintings and reliving my childhood, but with present feelings.” Rubenoff’s portrait captures the moment of innocence and the joys of imagining the unknown experiences of life to come. Terence Tavares a senior and second place winner of the Annual Juried Exhibition for his reduction woodcut piece, “Enjoy it while it lasts,” created a melting ice cream with the strong deliberate features of a human face. According to Tavares, he had chosen woodcut reduction because the wood grain becomes entwined with the image and its meaning. Just as ice cream is temporary, always in danger of melting, so is youth and beauty, which does not last as years go on. Tavares’ art is derived from everyday life, quotes, responses to events and new elements. “To me art is everywhere. People do art and don’t even notice,” said Tavares. “To me the creative process is when you have to explore yourself to discover the true you – why you do what you do.” Kendra Lohr, a former FSU student who transferred to Massachusetts College of Art and Design, also had her artwork, “I AM YELLING AT YOU” selected. Created with charcoal, stoneware, yarn and red acrylic painted onto the yarn, a figure’s limbs emerge from a box. At first glance, it seems to be a cat, simply playing with yarn, but a closer look reveals a human chin, eyes, nose and bare knee caps and elbows while the rest is coated in black charcoal. There is no mouth, giving an overwhelming haunted and isolated feeling. Lohr envisioned this piece three dimensionally, but as her hands molded the figure, it developed into the consolation of being powerless in terms of expression. After simplifying the eyes but paying attention to the texture of the fur and delicate limbs, the figure developed with human features, emotions and tension of the experience of interaction, even simply by eyesight, between people and an individual. Lohr believes that a person projects his or her views on individuals, yet individuals remain powerless to show their true selves and intentions. Yet with an interaction, people have the power of choosing whether or not they expose themselves. It is an act of will, according to Lohr. The symbolism of the closed box, Lohr explained, was “because it is something he [the figure] is in control of, unless someone were to go under the string and look inside. “Yet, there would still be not much to see because nothing has been given, and he chose not to reveal himself,” Lohr added. Melinda Collins, an art major with a concentration in graphic design, featured her sculpture, “Osseous.” Using clay as her medium, a new experience and doorway opened for Collins instead of her typical work on a computer screen. She contorted the clay into smooth curves and dwelling depths. The new experience of working with her hands, Collins said, was absolutely liberating. “It’s like therapy for me – being a commercial artist can sometimes be restricting,” said Collins. “I enjoy being able to let go and let my creativity take over.” After much positive feedback, especially about her sculpture looking like a bone structure, Collins then chose the name “Osseous.” The form, surprisingly was unintentional and developed as she went disposing, or rather destroying, parts that didn’t work, said Collins. In the end, “Osseous’” many contours all seemed to connect on an inner level, flowing into the next curve, dip and bulge as if each molding contributed to a larger meaning and energy unknown to the human eye. Candace Heim, a freshman who aspires to go into marketing, is the creator of “Stressed Out Strawberry,” done in charcoal. This piece features a suspended strawberry over a rural landscape. Within the strawberry, a face is harbored among the seeds that are delicately perfected. The face portrays an emotion, more of a sorrowful and distressed gaze. Elongated hands rest on the cheeks, framing the defined chin, as a finger pulls gently on the skin to reveal an inner eyelid. According to Heim, the face is particularly a baby’s face, sharing a glimpse into her motives, being playful and surreal with her artwork. Originally, Heim wanted to create contrast among colors of yellows, reds and oranges, but slowly transitioned into using charcoal, since it allows more wiggle room to get messy, she said. Heim did not expect her art piece to be featured. “My artwork and personality go hand in hand with each other,” said Heim. “Most people find me to be an oddball, and kind of out there – but I like that. … And, I’m a paradox in my own self.”
- My name is Owen: One transgender student’s journey into manhood
By Spencer Buell Editor-in-Chief Two years ago in early October, Owen is a sophomore, and he is standing out in the hallway on the fifth floor of the McCarthy Center, script in hand, poring over his lines. He has never been in a play before, but he is about to audition for “The Vagina Monologues.” His monologue – called “Coochie Snorcher,” written from the perspective of a young woman overcoming sexual abuse, and experiencing her first foray into lesbian sex – is one of the longest in the “Vaginas” catalogue. And like most of the production, it deals fairly candidly with sexuality. The character’s “coochie snorcher? That’s her vagina. At one point, she vividly describes being raped. Owen isn’t all that nervous, at least not for the audition. It is the thought of eventually being vulnerable on stage and confronting the sea of eyes watching him that is his real concern. He had missed the first round of auditions, but a slot opened up when one of the cast members dropped out of the show, and his friend Meghan Earle pushed him to try out. “She dragged me,” Owen says. “I enjoyed going to the shows and everything, but it never crossed my mind to actually try out for them.” Earle had given him a copy of the script a few days earlier, and he had read through it a few times, but it took some prodding during their afternoon class together to get him actually walking across State Street to the McCarthy Center, where the auditions were being held. When he finally gave in, Owen says he was just being a good sport. Close friend and “Vaginas” cast member Samantha Palmer remembers watching him practice, his five-foot-eleven-inch frame dressed in a pair of blue jeans and a buttonup shirt, mouthing the words over and over again as he waited for his turn to try out. He is laying on a fake southern drawl – the monologue is based on the story of a southern African-American woman – but Owen knows his accent is not all that convincing. As Palmer recalls that night, “I don’t think he thought he was going to get in at all.” He has never liked the mustard yellow paint on the walls of Club Room 3, where the production’s co-directors, who will be analyzing his performance, are sitting, and he is thinking about that when his name is called. “Amanda,” he hears. He opens door to the room, faces the directors where they are seated at the end of a long, oval-shaped wooden table, and gives it a shot. Back then, Owen went by a woman’s name, the one his mom and dad gave him when he was born in October of 1990 in a female body. But since the start of this semester, he is Owen. He came up with the name while writing a short story for a creative writing class. The main character, a man named Owen Alexander, he says, is “the kind of character that I know in every way. I know what his apartment looks like, how he would act in every situation.” Owen asked that his last name not be published here, not because he cares whether Framingham State students know he is a transgender man – he doesn’t – but for other reasons. He worries that potential employers, co-workers, or, anyone, really, might Google search his name and find out about his sexual identity before they even have the chance to get to know him. There are laws which limit what kinds of questions employers can ask job applicants during interviews, such as how old they are or whether they are married or have kids. In Massachusetts, whether their chosen genders match up with their biology is one of them. This year, Gov. Deval Patrick signed into law a bill that updated civil rights legislation to protect transgender men and women from discrimination when it comes to getting a job or a loan, or renting an apartment, among other provisions. But still, Google searches make measures aimed at preventing prejudice all the more complicated to enforce, so, for the sake of this story, Owen is Owen. Besides, he says, “It’s not the first thing you want people to know about you when they meet you, you know?” It was a few minutes before midnight when he got the call. He nailed that “Vagina Monologues” audition, and he got the part. “I genuinely could not believe it,” he says. He called Earle. She screamed. “If she were near me,” he says, “I think she would have tackled me to the ground.” It wasn’t until he hung up the phone that it hit him. “Great,” he thought. “Now what have I gotten myself into?” Cut to about five months later, and Owen is standing alone on the stage of the Forum in the McCarthy Center giving a smooth, sensual rendition of the “Coochie Snorcher” monologue with confidence and a relaxed swagger. He stopped performing it with a drawl months ago. He is doing this one like Owen. He delivers the monologue’s final lines, “You know, I realized later, she was my surprising, unexpected, politically incorrect salvation. She transformed my sorry-ass coochie snorcher, and raised it up into a kind of heaven,” and, to rousing applause, steps back behind the curtain. That year, he became a Vagina Warrior, a title he says he will carry with pride for the rest of his life. “I am so thankful for ‘Vaginas,’” he says, looking back. “It’s, like, a community, or a sorority, I guess.” He says by this point, he could probably recite about 80 percent of the play from memory. “The Vagina Monologues,” though, is strictly an all-female operation. Just as important as the rehearsal itself, every meeting includes a “Vagina Happy Time,” in which members talk about high and low points from the past week in a judgment-free zone. They also discuss women’s issues and relationship struggles, and often share deeply personal stories. Understandably, they prefer to do so without men around. “Sometimes, things get serious,” Owen says. “It is probably one of the most unique shows ever,” says Earle. “It’s not just one of those shows where you show up, you read your lines and you go home. … It kind of forces you to self-reflect a little bit. Its really empowering, too, because it really makes you re-evaluate, like, ‘OK, who am I? What is my sexuality, really?’” Despite two years of intimate involvement with the group, and the development of close relationships with many of its members, Owen presented Palmer and Earle, codirectors of this year’s production, with a conundrum: Owen is now a man, and men aren’t allowed. Earlier, Owen, Palmer and Earle had even talked about directing the show together. But Owen’s transition changed everything. When it comes to “Vagina Happy Time,” however, he says, “The thing is, I know exactly what they’re talking about. I know what it’s like to be raised as a woman. … I’m a total feminist. There is no way I can undo all the things that I am.” For Owen, the key underlying existential questions he will spend the rest of his life answering have become: What does it mean to be a man? What kind of a man does he want to be? What does this journey into manhood mean for him, his friends and his classmates? In the end, at least in the context of “The Vagina Monologues,” they settled on a solution. Despite his being a man, Owen could stay. “We knew he wanted to be there, and we wanted him there,” Palmer says, “and the rest doesn’t matter.” His days performing monologues, however, are over. “I couldn’t be on stage for that,” he says. “That would contradict, like, everything I’ve done.” Nevertheless, he has found other ways to contribute, drawing on his experience from years past to help make rehearsals run as smoothly as possible by collecting papers, taking notes and helping the cast members run through their lines. During auditions this semester, he often took the job of holding doors open for people as they walked by, and, in the process, earned the moniker “manservant,” which he doesn’t mind at all. But for much of the cast, many of them new first-year recruits who know him only as Owen, he still had to explain what he was doing there. At this point in his life, he is doing what he can to blend in as “just another guy,” but in that moment, being just another guy would mean giving up a part of his life that he loved. So, during one meeting in midOctober, he addressed the “Happy Time” crowd as its 45 members gazed back at him. “Listen,” he said to them. “I’m sure some of you are wondering why I’m here. My name is Owen. I have been in the ‘Vaginas’ show for two years now. My best friend is directing the show. I’m transitioning, and ‘Vaginas’ helped me find this out about myself. So I can’t actually be in the show, but I will be here with you.” While most people he knows have been accepting of Owen’s transition, a few have questioned his decision to begin living his life as a man. “I’ve had people say, ‘Oh, it’s just a selfesteem problem – that you don’t love yourself,’” he says. “And I’m like, ‘No, that’s not the thing. I think I’m great. I have no problems with my self. It’s the body that comes with it that causes me the problems if I think about it.’” For years, Owen has looked at pictures of himself and thought his physical appearance didn’t match up with his internalized conception of his identity. His jaw was too round. His hair wasn’t right. He had breasts. He would catch a glimpse of himself in reflective surfaces – bathroom mirrors, computer screens or the gigantic windows leading up to the entrance to the student center – and not like what he was seeing. He felt like a man, yet looked so unmistakably like a woman. “I would think, ‘Who let me go out in public like that? Why didn’t anyone tell me that what I was thinking was not right?’ he says. “But no one knew about that discrepancy but me.” On his worst days, he worried he would one day wake up and realize he was schizophrenic – that the woman he had been seeing in the mirror could not possibly be him, that all this time, he had been “seeing something that wasn’t there.” Now, though, when he shows up at school or work and looks most like Owen, he feels most like Owen, and that helps. “Sometimes,” he says, “I’ll look in the mirror and be like, ‘Dang. You look good.’” He felt comfortable interacting with guys at his high school, but since he arrived at college, he has felt much more at ease with his group of female friends. These days, though, he finds he freezes up in situations in which he is surrounded by men. “I don’t even know what to say or what to do,” he says, sighing and throwing up his hands. “I just feel like they can see right through me.” He hopes that, one day, he will be able to make and sustain friendships with guys to whom his masculinity is not inexorably linked to his sex. As much as he wants to, Owen has yet to experience that priceless feeling of being welcomed and included by a group of men. “I feel completely feminine when I’m with biological males,” he says. “It’s horrible. It’s really horrible, actually.” He has a habit of studying people’s faces when they meet him for the first time – watching them scan his face and torso searching for visual cues about who he is as a person. “Their eyes give them away,” he says. He tries not to, but he can’t help it. Every encounter is different, but sometimes, people take his gender at face value. He will walk into a room, introduce himself, and no one thinks twice about his name or his appearance. It’s called “passing” – when his gender identity and people’s perceptions of it line up. “It’s a big thing for him,” says Kimmi Awiszio, Owen’s girlfriend. Over Thanksgiving, Owen met a group of Awiszio’s relatives for the first time. Her parents and sister know all about his transition, but her aunt and uncle had no idea. To save himself the disappointment later, he has to be careful not to assume people will see him as a man. But after an afternoon of sharing turkey and mashed potatoes at the same table, Awiszio had some good news for Owen. “Just to let you know,” she told him, “the people you just met? They didn’t have any question about it whatsoever.” He had passed. Among the high points of Owen’s life now are those moments when he sees the body he wants to, and the tiny victories that come with them. It is about more than just “passing,” he says. It is about feeling as if he can participate in the world around him without any social barriers. It is about being present. Before starting the fall semester this year, Owen sent an e-mail to his professors asking if they would, please, from that point on, call him by his chosen name and refer to him with male pronouns – that is, “he” instead of “she”; not “her” seminar thesis, but “his.” This was it. He was coming out to the FSU community at large. The classmate and student his peers had once known as a woman would now be living as a man. No more persistent auditory reminders of a gender that wasn’t his. No more daily dissonance in those moments he would answer a question, hand in a paper or have one passed back to him. Owen would be Owen. “It didn’t seem real,” he says. Dr. Lorretta Holloway of FSU’s English department remembers the day Owen’s email popped up on her computer screen. Her first thought was, “Why ‘Owen,’ of all the names in the world?” Apparently, Holloway thought he looked more like a “Jeremy.” After years of teaching and raising two daughters, Holloway knows what transitions look like, and remembers not being fazed. Rarely do students walk across the graduation stage much resembling the people they were when they first arrived at school, and she has seen plenty of the comedy and drama that emerges along the way. When Owen was a first-year, a time in students’ lives often characterized by turmoil and drastic reassessment, she remembers him being exceptionally calm and calculating, poised and self-aware. “He never seemed to be the kind of person who made hasty, emotional decisions,” Holloway says. “If I got an e-mail where he had said, ‘You know what? This is my e-mail to say goodbye. I’ve decided to become a Buddhist monk,’ I would be like, “Oh, OK,’ because I know that this is something that has really been thought through.” So, in preparation for the first day of their British Literature II class together, Holloway scanned the list to the middle where the name “Amanda” was printed. She crossed it off, for good. That day in September, she stood at the front of the class, the list in her left hand, a pencil in her right, and began calling out names. Present. Check. Present. Check. Holloway had not yet passed out the syllabus for that semester, but Owen had one on his desk next to his notebook. He knew he would have a rigorous course load this semester, so he wanted to get started early. More names. Present. Check. The class consists of a combination of people who knew Owen by his old name, but knew he was transitioning, people who were hearing the new name for the first time, and people who didn’t know him at all. But everyone, in that moment, was about to learn what they were to call him. He and Holloway briefly made eye contact, and she said it. “Owen,” he heard. He was present. Holloway admits that, after almost four years of knowing Owen as a woman, she has struggled sometimes to remember which pronouns to use. “He teases me all the time because I spend a lot of time saying ‘Owen’ and not using the pronoun because I’m so concerned that I’m going to mess up,” she says. She has encouraged him to remind her when she slips in a stray “she” here and there, which is a particularly obvious mistake in their four-member, all-male Seminar in Literature class. He makes sure that he does. Using the correct pronoun when speaking about him takes only a quarter of a second, but it is in those quick, fleeting moments that he faces either acknowledgement of his identity or nullification of it. People make mistakes all the time without meaning to, though, and he tries to brush it off when it happens, even on those tough days when it hurts more than people realize. Holloway, who Owen considers to be among the two or three professors with whom he is closest, is trying. “I give her props,” he says. Some problems still come up, though. For example, in FSU records, as well as the ones held by his health care provider Harvard Pilgrim, the DMV, and just about everyone else, he is still referred to by his birth name. His school-provided e-mail address still bears his old name, as does his profile on electronic learning tool Blackboard, on which a lot of work for classes is carried out, which sometimes generates confusion among some of his classmates, many of whom didn’t know him before his transition. Changing his name, legally that is, will be a costly, time-consuming process. “It’s just a lot of paperwork and a lot of paying for paperwork,” he says. First, as a resident of Millbury, he will have to fill out a form, appear at Worcester County Probate and Family Court and pay a $185 fee. On the line where he is asked for his “reason for name change,” he will write “personal.” Then, he will have to get a new social security card, driver’s license and so on – and fork over more fees. “Then it’s going through all those other things – dentist, credit card company – and basically anything else that has your name on it,” he says. “Just pick up the phone and keep calling people.” He has copies of most of what he will need on file, and all the necessary steps are on his to-do list. But his friends and family know who he is, and so do his teachers. His nametag at the hotel where he works as a housekeeper says “Owen.” The people he sees on a regular basis know who he is and what to call him. So for now, he’s just saving up some money and working on finishing off this semester before he straightens things out with official record-keepers in the state of Massachusetts, who, as far as he is concerned, do not know him at all. Time is running out, though. Owen is graduating this spring, and when he is called to walk across the stage on the Village Green in May, he wants to hear his name. Owen’s FTM, or female-to-male, transition really began a few years ago, when he started coming to terms with the fact that the body he had been born with did not accurately represent his gender. Before he had ever taken his first steps officially coming out as a transgender man, Owen’s transition was a step-by-step process of expressing his feelings to college friends and relatives, often one at a time. This would not be his first time coming out, though. During his junior year of high school, Owen came out as a lesbian. At Millbury High, his graduating class was about 150-strong, and most already knew him pretty well. “A lot of people weren’t surprised,” he says. “They were just like, ‘OK, good. I’m glad that you finally said that because we just got tired of you prancing around and pretending that you’re not.’” He stopped wearing typical women’s clothes by about sophomore year, after realizing he felt much more comfortable in baggy jeans or basketball shorts than in more feminine choices. At his school’s semiformal dance senior year, when most women were donning gender-specific dresses and skirts, he wore a dark gray pair of pants and a vest, a teal dress shirt which matched his girlfriend’s outfit, and a white tie. Two years later, sometime over winter break during their sophomore year at FSU, Earle and Owen, then “Amanda,” had planned to go dancing at Mirabar, a gay club in Providence. Earle’s first memory of Owen is from first-year orientation, when the new arrivals to FSU were introduced, split into groups and, as Earle puts it, made “to do all these stupid skits” together. Owen was assigned the role of a fairy tale character, and, Earle says, he was hilarious. “That person is so funny,” she thought. She had to meet Amanda. They ended up being lab partners, and by luck, happened to be in at least one class together for three straight years. They hit it off even before they had technically started their college careers, she said. “It was one of those immediate friendships.” So, in addition to hanging out during the school year, the pair started getting together over breaks, going to dinner at each other’s houses and so on. This night, they were going to Mirabar. When they arrived, Owen realized he had forgotten his driver’s license, so they couldn’t get in, and what followed was a long drive home and lots of time to talk. At around 11 p.m., just a few minutes from home, Owen and Earle were sitting in Earle’s car, the upbeat pop rock of Andre 3000 coming through her speakers, waiting for a stoplight to turn green. “I don’t know how to tell you this,” he heard himself say, “but I don’t feel like a girl. I picture myself with a beard, and I want to be able to shave my face.” Sitting in the commuter cafeteria in December, a few minutes late for her Monday night “Vagina Monologues” rehearsal, Earle is smiling and fluffing some imaginary facial hair as she recalls the moment. At that stoplight, they shared a laugh. “I said to him, ‘You know, if you grow a beard, you need to let me, like, touch your face. It’s going to be so much fun.” They ended that night sitting on Earle’s couch shopping for binders – special clothing otherwise known as “compression garments” designed to help reduce the visibility of breasts. Owen didn’t have a debit card at the time, so Earle offered to buy one for him. The beard was out of his control, at least for now, but his chest? He could start taking care of that immediately. They could take care of it together. “He just seemed really relieved,” Earle says. Two weeks before his first therapy session with Diane Ellaborn, a gender identity specialist, Owen met Kimmi. Awiszio was a first-year at the time, and while both were going to “Vaginas” meetings in January, she developed what she calls a “stupid crush” on him. She was too nervous to approach him, but after some friendly intervention from Earle, she learned Owen had a “stupid crush” on her, too. At that point, Awiszio identified as a lesbian, and she still does today. Labels, she says, have a way of making people a lot less complicated than they really are. She has had boyfriends in the past, but by her eighth grade year at a “hardcore Christian school,” she knew she was attracted to girls. She knew Owen as “Amanda” then, and she really, really liked Amanda. They started talking and hanging out more and more often, and soon, they were a couple. When he broke the news about his identity, though, her heart sank. Did this mean she was attracted to guys now? Would this mean she wasn’t a lesbian anymore? What would her label be? Today, the two are all but inseparable. Awiszio spends at least half of the week staying at Owen’s home in Millbury. She doesn’t own a car, but Owen happily drives her everywhere in his 2003 Saturn Ion – to work, to school, to her house, to his. They take time out of marathons of homework to appreciate the simple pleasures of playing Lego Star Wars on his Wii. They feel a mutual disdain for his turtle, named “Turtle,” whose glass terrarium they reluctantly take turns cleaning. Their relationship, she says, just works. She can’t even remember the last time they had an argument. “We have this thing where we can just feel each other,” she says. “Like, when he’s having a bad day, I can feel it in my stomach, and when I’m having a bad day, he can feel it, too.” They have learned to communicate without having to use words, but that day, just a few weeks after the start of their relationship, words mattered. “I’m doing this,” he told her. I’m transitioning. And he wanted Awiszio to be with him on this journey. She understood. Owen is currently on the hunt for an apartment – this summer, they will be moving in together. It’s a big step, but why not? Kimmi likes Owen for Owen, and that, she says, is all she needs to know. It’s a Friday morning in mid-July, and Owen is sitting on a hospital recliner chair at the Amherst Medical Center, a needle hovering two inches over his right thigh. He is wearing a green UConn sweatshirt, a black fitted hat on backwards and what appears to be an expectant smile. His mom frames him up in the viewfinder of a Canon digital camera. She clicks the shutter. For the next four-and-a-half months, that image would be his Facebook profile picture – a place of prominence in the Digital Age, where users showcase the version of themselves they think best represents who they are at a particular time and place. In it, Owen is about to take testosterone, .25 milliliters of it, for the first time. The night before, Awiszio had been staying at his house, helping him get ready for his appointment. They had to be up at 5 a.m. – an hour-long ride on the Massachusetts Turnpike awaited them. It was going to be an early night. To her surprise, Awiszio was crying. “I am scared this is going to change you,” she said to him. Getting to this point had not been easy. Just to get an appointment, Owen had to take the required first step to set the process in motion. He had to start seeing Diane Ellaborn, a therapist and advocate with 30 years of experience working with trans people, about a tenth of them college students for whom the transitional experience of being an undergraduate includes a newly discovered dissociation with their biological gender. With Ellaborn, Owen had to start from the very beginning. For four months, he talked about his childhood – what kinds of movies he liked, what kinds of toys he played with, what he wore at Halloween, what his relationship was like with his sister. He told Ellaborn that among his fondest early memories was “shaving with my grampy” – pretending to, at least, and patting his cheeks with scented white lather. Then came the questionnaire, the one produced by his insurance provider as a way to peek into his psychological state and, later, to track his progress. In the past year, had he ever felt as if he had been born in the wrong body? Easy. Yes. The work Ellaborn does with her clients, though, extends far beyond the conversations that take place in her office three miles from the FSU campus on Edmands Road. Her circle of contacts includes a group of healthcare professionals who have undergone sensitivity training with her. She is on a first-name basis with them, and she makes sure they attend to the small, but important details, such as not assuming that a patient’s name is reflected accurately in their medical records. “A gender specialist, to me, should really be looking at the whole person and their overall health,” she says. “I’m very hands-on.” Ellaborn would eventually fax a letter to Dr. Stuart Chipkin’s endocrinology clinic in Amherst. “It is my professional opinion that, although biologically female, Amanda aka Owen meets the DSM IV criteria for Gender Identity Disorder,” it said. The discomfort Owen had felt for years finally had an official diagnosis, and with it, a “cure.” That term, “identity disorder,” will be stricken from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, or DSM, when the next edition comes out over the summer. In its place, the manual will list “dysphoria,” the opposite of “euphoria,” and the scientific term for the feeling Owen gets in the pit of his stomach on the days he feels least like himself. Someone calls him “she.” He has to do group work with male classmates. He remembers that his e-mail address starts with an “A,” for “Amanda.” Dysphoria. Currently, however, in order to get the drugs he needs – a monthly one milliliter supply of testosterone, or “T,” for short – he had to be diagnosed with a “disorder.” He is not completely comfortable with that reality, but, he says, “You know what? It gets me what I need to get. So if they want to call it a ‘disorder,’ OK. Fine.” Hormone replacement therapy will have some so-called “masculinizing” effects on Owen. His larynx will become enlarged. His voice will drop by about an octave. His jaw line will start to tighten up. He will develop some extra muscle mass and body hair. And hopefully, he says, he will get his beard. Before he could get started, though, he had to start making regular trips back and forth to appointments around the state – all with Ellaborn’s help. On top of everything else on his plate this semester, he has had to switch his primary care physician, get frequent blood tests to monitor his cholesterol levels, which can spike once people start taking “T,” and meet with a nutritionist. He stores the dozens of prescriptions, letters and lab results he has amassed over the last year neatly organized in a three-ringed binder, but keeping track of all of his new medical responsibilities can sometimes be overwhelming, and he can’t imagine doing it alone. “I’m just really glad that I have Diane,” he says. He would have to get over the next major obstacle, however, without her. Owen has a crippling fear of needles. Before his appointment, he had to track down a special, smaller one with a gauge, or needle width, of 25, the second-smallest available – just wide enough for the oily hormone to fit through a tiny hole at its end. After repeated trips to other pharmacies, he finally tracked down a set of them at a Walgreens in Worcester, and they were with him as he drove to Chipkin’s clinic, dreading what was to come. His cat Hailey has diabetes, and he can give her the insulin shots she needs without flinching. However, there is something about injecting himself that causes him to panic. Back on the hospital chair, a specialist is walking him through the process. His mom is there with the camera, waiting for the moment to come. Owen slowly pulls back the plunger, filling a syringe, bit by bit, with about half the amount of liquid one might use to clean contact lenses, making sure no bubbles get inside. An instructional sheet of paper tells him to pick one of a few fatty areas for the injection: just above the knee, the back of his arm, in one butt cheek. He doesn’t have to find a vein, but the trick is to avoid hitting any nerves. He picks the knee. Holding the syringe in his right hand, he stretches the skin tight with the thumb and index finger of his left. His mom thinks he is about to do it, so she takes the picture. But he can’t. He keeps imagining the tip of the needle breaking through each individual layer of skin, then scraping up against his bone. He knows he is being irrational, but he is frozen. Months and months of soulsearching and planning, trips to doctors’ offices, blood tests, check-ups, late-night confessions and last-minute tears, and only two inches separate him and his medicine. He feels a nurse’s palm against his hand, gently moving it down toward his leg. He holds his breath. In it goes. “It’s been four months now, and he’s still the same guy,” Awiszio says. The “T,” so far, has not made Owen any less like Owen. He has yet to get over his needle phobia, and after weeks of watching him struggle to inject the “T,” Awiszio decided to start doing it for him – every Friday, just before they leave for school together. “I’m still afraid that I’m going to hurt him,” she says, “but I’ve gotten used to it now.” He will have to become accustomed to self-administering eventually, though. Because the human body doesn’t absorb and store testosterone, hormone treatments have to be undertaken regularly for life. Occasionally, because of the high levels of hormone in his system in the days just after he takes his “T,” Owen will feel a brief rush of energy surge through his body. His heart races, and he immediately feels the need to get up and move – jump around, hysterically clean his room, anything. Fast. Two days after that first appointment, he literally ran laps around his house, then lifted Awiszio off the ground in a giant bear hug. The euphoria comes in a wave, which eventually recedes. By the time Thursday rolls around, he finds that “I’m just getting slower and grumpier.” By Friday night, he starts feeling better. Each month, his prescription provides him with one small vial holding one milliliter, or four doses, and four needles. The needles are $13 each – “which doesn’t make any sense,” he says – but the hormones are covered entirely by his insurance provider Harvard Pilgrim. And that’s a big deal, says Dr. Lori Girshick, author of “Transgender Voices: Beyond Women and Men.” In her book, she chronicles the many ways in which people have historically procured hormone treatments – paying for big bills out of pocket, buying vials on the street, finding it on the Internet and flying it in from other countries – when insurance companies won’t cover it. Owen is very much aware of how lucky he is. Regardless of how difficult everything else will be, getting his monthly “T” is easy. Testosterone therapy, however, is just the first in what could be many, potentially costly, steps. A significant number of serious decisions will need to be made throughout Owen’s adult life based on how he answers two fundamental questions: What will it take to make Owen the man he wants to be? To what lengths is he willing to go to become himself? He has begun setting his sights on breast reduction, also known as “top surgery,” but, he says, that won’t be for a while. “It’s, like, the cost of a car,” he says, somewhere in the neighborhood of $6,000 – $7,000, depending on the surgeon, and as an elective, cosmetic surgery, it is not covered by insurance. The use of breast binders works for now, though, and he says they are much better than the old-fashioned Ace bandage method. The problem with using the medical wrap is that it can be kind of clunky and way too tight, so much so that using them for too long can do damage to the user’s rib cage and make it hard to breathe. Binders from websites like Underworks.com are tailored to an individual’s specific breast size, and are just tight enough to flatten out his chest without hurting him. They will have to do. Sex reassignment surgery, on the other hand, is less of a big deal for him. When he was younger, he remembers thinking, “I have to do all of it, or I’m not going to be a real man.” But after all that he has learned about himself and about the transience of gender, whether he has a penis has started to seem inconsequential. The procedure is also tens of thousands of dollars more expensive than top surgery, and, he says, “I don’t have to spend that much money to get something that no one’s going see besides my partner, who is obviously going to love me no matter what.” Owen still has hundreds of old photos of himself and records of conversations with friends posted all over social networking sites – years and years of memories from before his transition – and the question now is what to do with them. Trans men and women respond differently to the challenges Facebook poses, some of them doing away with their old sites completely, starting new ones as soon as they begin going by their new names. Owen says he can’t change the fact that he lived most of his life as a woman, nor would he. But he can’t help but feel that some of those pictures just don’t look like him. He hasn’t come to a decision about what to do with that years-long catalog of his life, but Owen the Vagina Warrior, Owen the poet, the writer, the actor, the feminist, the friend, is embracing them for the time being. He is leaving his Facebook site as it is. He is looking more and more like a guy as the weeks go on, tracking his progress on a Tumblr blog called “A Gentleman’s Beard,” where he posts periodic picture updates. The site was Awiszio’s idea. Owen’s physiological changes are significant, but she says they can be subtle for those who see him every day, and might not notice his evolution otherwise. He does look different, and Awiszio wants him to recognize it. The prefix “trans” in the word “transgender” means “across,” “beyond,” or “through.” “It’s not a static term,” says Girshick. “It means movement.” For Owen, it is a state of being, a journey, the beginning and end of which are nearly impossible to pin down. He is still coming to terms with what it means to be a man. So what, finally, does that mean? “I think that I’m doing it already,” Owen says, with finals on the horizon and the semester coming to a close. “I just don’t think that other people see it. It’s just that I feel the need to have that physical representation – the beard, the deeper voice and everything – not to be misgendered all the time. After his latest round of blood tests in September, Owen learned that the testosterone levels in his body were at 396 nanograms per deciliter and rising – up from 44 before he started hormone replacement therapy. Typical levels in males are somewhere between 300 – 1,100. Chemically, technically, he is in the biological range. He doesn’t make too big a deal of this, though. Of all the components that make a man, chemistry is just a minor element. Social roles are more important. Last month, his sister Heather gave birth to a baby boy named Benjamin, and just after he was born, Owen held him in his arms. This was his nephew. Benjamin will have an uncle. And just last night, at the first-annual Miss FSU contest, Owen was Monique Vacon’s escort for the formal wear portion of the event. He wore a slick black suit and a white tie, and casually walked Vacon across the broad stage of the Dwight Performing Arts Center. His role, he says, was to make her look good. Owen is coming to understand that he can define manhood on his own terms. His identity, he says, “is about being a good person and holding doors open and caring about people. In the end, I just want to take all the good things about both genders, and make them into one.” Owen wants to be all the things that he is. He wants to be Owen. His profile picture – the one of him holding the “T” needle? He changed it just after the Miss FSU contest concluded last night. In the new photo, he is leaning forward in the front row of the DPAC auditorium, a wide grin across his face. His jaw line looks tight. His chest is flat. He looks different, and he knows it. He spent four months with the same Facebook picture up, and last night was as good a time as ever to change it, and show himself to the world the way he wants to be seen. Dang, he thought. I look good.



